COMMENT

Property development promotion as community planning participation

If the Liveable Exeter property development scheme and its Exeter Development Fund financing vehicle are already intended to ‘anchor and underpin’ the new Exeter Local Plan, what will public consultation on the plan decide?

Martin Redfern

After fronting a pair of Liveable Exeter property development scheme promotional events in an empty High Street retail unit in May and June, it was RAMM’s turn to host a third at its Queen Street museum headquarters in July.

Ostensibly Lego-led, all three events have sought to convey the idea that the council is keen to invite residents to have their say on how the new Exeter Local Plan should frame spatial development in the city until 2040.

Touted as a “once in a generation opportunity to reimagine what the city could look like” much of the thinking around the 12,000 homes the council is determined to build whether or not Exeter needs them has nevertheless already been done.

As council development director Ian Collinson recently said, the council intends the Liveable Exeter scheme to “anchor and underpin” the new local plan, and the scheme’s financing vehicle, Exeter Development Fund, depends in turn on a series of assumptions that have already been made about what Liveable Exeter development should be and whose interests it should serve.

These include that all the housing should be for rent, not purchase, in order to extract sufficient profit to pay the interest demanded by bankrolling private financiers, and that few units will be suitable for family occupation with none for social housing.

Central government, which is paying Exeter City Futures to engineer the fund, will retain effective control throughout, and the council will have to sell publicly-owned land and property assets to a third-party development corporation to make it happen.

Liveable Exeter community engagement with council development director Ian Collinson Liveable Exeter community engagement with council development director Ian Collinson

Last month’s RAMM event showcased the council’s approach to the community participation in local plan development it needs to demonstrate to get the plan past the planning inspectorate.

The audience was presented with a demo of an online-only “Future Place” survey which invited participants to choose between prescribed options presented as vague abstractions rather than concrete proposals.

None addressed the development delivery financing priorities which look set to turn the Liveable Exeter scheme into a gentrification engine.

Answers that were allowed to “Which is most important for the future of this place?” included “Streets for living, playing and relaxing: not just for travel” and “A vibrant neighbourhood: all the things I require nearby”. None related to affordability or prioritising housing for local people.

Nor was there an explanation of how the findings derived from non-statutory consultation approaches such as this, or the Lego models and post-it notes which were the primary input methods at the “RAMM About Town” events that took place in May and June, will actually be incorporated into the new plan.

The council has so far failed to answer questions about how this might work, but does say it will “consider” what it calls “feedback”.

Exeter City Council RAMM lego Exeter Live Better policy promotion as museum exhibit Council planning policy promotion as museum exhibit – “Picture yourself in the leafy green, sustainable Exeter of the future”

Apart from council members and officers, it appeared few present were convinced by the “Future Place” survey demo.

While the choice of tools had clearly shaped its design, there was no escaping the contention that its content should have been derived differently. By actually talking to people first, as several suggested.

However as the survey was due to go live the same week, the prospects for pre-launch community consultation looked poor, particularly as its findings are supposed to be included in the draft plan which is due in September.

(As there’s still no sign of the survey a fortnight later, who knows what role it will now play.)

Audience members also mentioned the poor quality of recent Exeter development in areas including Monkerton and Newcourt and pointed out that what’s needed to make places work for residents is already well-understood.

The council’s stock rejoinder to this sort of criticism has become to blame the planning system, repeatedly, then cite Exeter Development Fund as the solution.

Not that the contradiction entailed by encouraging people to get involved in developing new planning policy while telling them that planning policy doesn’t work is entirely lost on all those involved.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

However it is not the fault of the planning system that the council has not introduced promised policies to restrict the impact of inexorably rising student numbers on the city’s residential housing stock, or to prevent developers pretending that enormous blocks of sub-standard bedsits are not intended for student occupation simply by calling them “co-living”.

Nor is the planning system responsible for the council not setting higher standards than the national Building Regulations for energy efficiency or introducing other improved design quality standards.

Instead the council has been postponing the introduction of needed new planning policies for the past two years on the grounds the new local plan is on its way, although its adoption will not take place until June 2024 at the earliest.

It appears it has become so fixated on delivering the Liveable Exeter scheme, and lining up Exeter Development Fund to finance it, that it is prepared to let developers carry on regardless in the rest of the city while it spends years putting together its plans for a handful of sites.

Whether the planning system reforms the government intends to introduce as part of its Levelling Up and Regeneration Bill, which is expected to become law before Exeter’s new local plan reaches examination stage, will lay the council’s carefully-contrived plans to waste remains to be seen.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription from £8.50/month to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
Vaughan Road development site phase two groundworks

Council to mothball Exeter City Living Vaughan Road flats after first phase leaving £2.75m groundworks fenced off

Twelve year-old plan to rebuild remaining pre-war Laing’s Easiform council houses in Buddle Lane estate to be seen through to completion instead, as undelivered local housing promises finally collide with reality.

Proposed floor plans and elevations

Plan for student accommodation block in back garden of 17-bed Pennsylvania Road HMO dismissed at appeal

City council planning consent refusal upheld by inspector in decision citing existing community balance policy that is not retained in proposed new Exeter Local Plan.

Hotel Indigo Exeter

Singapore hospitality group buys Hotel Indigo Exeter for £19.4 million

Sale of converted House of Fraser department store announced one week after Frasers Group purchase of adjacent Princesshay shopping centre.

, updated

Topsham Golf Academy development site view

Topsham gap greenfield development application submitted for approval

Proposals for 54 dwellings on Exeter Golf and Country Club Topsham Golf Academy driving range enabled by city council approval of replacement driving range in Ludwell Valley Park.

InExeter Business Improvement District operational area map crop

Exeter Business Improvement District seeks third five-year term to April 2030

Eligible city centre businesses to decide by ballot whether InExeter should continue providing services and support in return for 1.25% levy charged against premises with £7,500+ rateable value.

An onboard bus service information announcement display on a London bus

New rules compel Stagecoach South West to introduce real-time onboard bus journey information

Around 40% of company’s Exeter fleet requires accessibility improvements including automated screens and announcements by next October, with remainder due in following twelve months.

On Our Radar
London Concertante in performance

FRIDAY 8TH NOVEMBER 2024

The Four Seasons & The Lark Ascending

An evening of classical music by candlelight performed by London Concertante.

EXETER CATHEDRAL

Poltimore House 2023 Christmas market

SATURDAY 9 & SUNDAY 10 NOVEMBER 2024

Poltimore Christmas markets

Four weekend festive markets with stalls selling local arts and crafts.

POLTIMORE HOUSE

2013 production of War Horse at the Sydney Lyric theatre

WEDNESDAY 13 NOVEMBER 2024

War Horse concert

Michael Morpurgo reading an abridged version of his best-known work, accompanied by musician Ben Murray.

EXETER CATHEDRAL