NEWS

Planning inspector discounts highways authority responses to dismiss Redhills housing appeal

Decision concludes that development on former vehicle breaker’s yard would have posed ‘substantial danger’ to pedestrians and drivers in rural lane on city outskirts.

Leigh Curtis

A planning inspector has dismissed an appeal for a development of six detached five-bedroom residential dwellings on a brownfield site in Redhills. The site was previously a scrapyard, known as Newbery Car Breakers, whose owner was given a suspended prison sentence in 2018 for operating an illegal vehicle dismantling business there.

An application for full planning permission to redevelop the site was submitted by a subsequent owner in May 2022.

The city council planning committee considered the application in April last year but deferred its decision to its June meeting to allow officers time to formulate its refusal reasons. These centred on highways safety as a result of the scrapyard’s location in a rural lane, without pedestrian footpaths and bordered by deep hedgerows, on the city’s outskirts near Nadderwater.

However, before the June meeting took place the applicant submitted an appeal against the council’s failure to determine the application within the statutory time limit. A planning inspector dismissed the appeal earlier this month.

Illustrative elevation of development proposals Illustrative elevation of development proposals. Image: Squirrel Design.

Devon County Council’s response to the site redevelopment application, as local highways authority, only ran to a single, 100-word paragraph. It saw no reason to object.

It mentioned an outline planning permission for an adjacent site that had been granted at appeal in February 2022, which includes a condition requiring the provision of a pedestrian footway to which the scrapyard development might expect to connect.

However it failed to acknowledge that it had recommended refusal of the adjacent site application on the grounds it is “an unsustainable location with inadequate access to pedestrian and cycling facilities and very limited access to public transport” which makes it likely to “become car-dependent with limited opportunities to travel by sustainable means”.

It also mentioned its response to a previous planning application for the scrapyard site, for which outline planning permission was granted in July 2018 shortly after the scrapyard owner was sentenced, but then lapsed three years later.

It said that as that response had been that it “would not need a footway due to the low numbers of pedestrian movements that it would likely generate”, and the new application was “for one more dwelling” than before, it “would not likely increase the pedestrian movements significantly more in order for the highway authority to raise an objection”.

However its response to the previous application was also for a development of six, not five, detached dwellings. It said: “Given the application is on a brownfield site (a scrapyard), the level of additional traffic generation from the site is expected to be modest and the additional traffic generated is not a significant concern.”

No explanation was offered as to why the vehicle movements related to a scrapyard might provide a guide to those resulting from a housing development providing 24 off-road car-parking spaces.

Illustrative plan of development proposals Illustrative plan of development proposals. Image: Squirrel Design.

The city council planning officer’s report on the scrapyard application echoed the county council’s lack of concern about the lack of a pedestrian footpath. It also cited the outline permission on the adjacent site and repeated the claim that the impact on local roads would be insignificant, again citing the site’s “previous use as a breaker’s yard”.

Committee members saw the situation differently at the planning committee meeting which heard the application, which a county council highways officer did not attend even though it took place at County Hall.

They criticised the application’s failure both to provide safe pedestrian and cyclist access to the site and to promote sustainable transport modes. They said the resulting car-dependent development would produce an unacceptable risk of conflict between road users, harming highways safety.

The planning inspector agreed with the councillors, whose refusal reasons were confirmed at the planning committee’s June meeting after the appeal had been lodged.

Rural lane in Redhills beside former vehicle breakers yard Rural lane in Redhills beside former vehicle breakers yard. Image: Exeter City Council.

The inspector said, disagreeing with the county council, that the scrapyard is “an unsuitable location for new residential development” when access to sustainable modes of transport and highway safety are considered, and that the proposed development would conflict with several Exeter Local Plan policies.

They said there had been “numerous vehicles moving in both directions” past the site entrance during their visit in February, and that steep banks on both sides of the road precluded both pedestrians getting out of the way of passing vehicles and vehicles safely passing pedestrians.

They added: “A pedestrian walking in the road for this relatively short distance, particularly when it is dark, poses a substantial danger to themselves and drivers” and so a “significant risk to highway safety”.

The inspector also concluded that the development proposals failed to promote sustainable transport modes, including access to public transport, instead of private motor vehicle use.

They added that there was no guarantee that the pedestrian footpath required as a condition of the outline permission for the adjacent site would be delivered as the reserved matters application that would address all remaining aspects of that development had not then come forward.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

The appeal decision follows a judicial review of a city council planning decision at St Bridget Nurseries in Old Rydon Lane in which the judge found that Devon County Council had “failed to discharge its statutory duty” as local highway authority.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
Eutopia Homes Exmouth Junction build to rent development rear elevation

First Exeter build to rent flats marketed at £1,375-£2,350 per month with “affordable” units costing £1,080-£1,800 plus bills

Eutopia Homes rents in Exmouth Junction block would leave many workers with substantially lower income than Joseph Rowntree Foundation minimum for a socially-acceptable standard of living.

Northbrook Swimming Pool campaign demonstration Exeter Guildhall 13 May 2025

Campaigners compel Exeter City Council to reconsider Northbrook pool closure with 2,250-strong resident petition

Pressure on council intensifies after freedom of information request responses confirm £3.5 million budget cuts included potentially unlawful decision to close swimming pool without public consultation or impact assessment.

Wild camping on Dartmoor

Supreme Court rejects Dartmoor landowners’ attempt to prevent wild camping on their land

Judges unanimously dismiss appeal by Alexander and Diana Darwall against 2023 ruling upholding Dartmoor Commons Act as campaigners call for enhanced public rights to access nature pledged by Labour when still in opposition.

Child on park bench

Ofsted finds Devon County Council children’s services remain “inadequate” with rating unchanged since 2020

Inspection report highlights “serious weaknesses” that are “leaving children at risk of harm” as failings echo poor Special Educational Needs & Disabilities provision.

Mid Devon District Council headquarters at Phoenix House in Tiverton

Mid Devon District Council mischarged 2,865 social housing tenants £15.5 million in rent over twenty years

Housing regulator identifies “serious failings” in application of rent standard as council discovers dozens of evictions in which “rent arrears were the sole, or contributory factor”.

Dartmoor wildfire on 5 May 2025, photo by Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Service

Dartmoor National Park warns of continued high fire risk after wildfire destroys 1,230 acres of moorland

Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Service took nearly 24 hours to extinguish bank holiday weekend blaze that followed warning of uncontrolled moorland fire risk.

On Our Radar
Exeter Respect Festival

SATURDAY 7 & SUNDAY 8 JUNE 2025

Exeter Respect Festival 2025

The annual celebration of Exeter diversity returns for its 28th anniversary with live music and performance, food stalls, community and campaign groups.

BELMONT PARK

Exeter City Of Literature literary map

SUNDAY 8 JUNE 2025

The Book Market 2025

Exeter City of Literature event features independent booksellers from across the county with author talks, stalls, food and drink.

CATHEDRAL GREEN

Exeter Custom House

SUNDAY 8 JUNE 2025

Heritage Harbour Festival 2025

The maritime-themed event returns for a third year with steam boats, exhibitions, talks, live music, film screenings and more.

EXETER QUAY

Art Week Exeter 2025 graphic

MONDAY 9 TO SUNDAY 15 JUNE 2025

Art Week Exeter 2025

Festival returns with exhibitions, film screenings, talks, workshops, performances, social events and an art car boot sale.

EXETER CITY CENTRE

Pipe organ keyboard in St Mary's Church, Throwleigh by Andrew Abbott

SATURDAY 14 JUNE 2025

Lost and Found (Keyboards Revoiced)

Exeter Contemporary Sounds and Ian Summers perform works on rescued, repurposed and reimagined instruments.

EXETER LIBRARY

Exeter Philharmonic Choir in Exeter Cathedral

SATURDAY 14 JUNE 2025

A Feast of English Choral Music

Exeter Philharmonic Choir performs works by English composers.

EXETER CATHEDRAL