Good journalism costs money  Upgrade to paid

COMMENT

Net Zero Exeter accountability under scrutiny

Exeter City Council’s response to the climate crisis has so far been characterised by numerous failings. Unfortunately its attitude towards accountability for its actions in this area is also cause for concern.

Martin Redfern

Exeter City Council’s response to the climate crisis has so far been characterised by numerous failings. It has failed to question flawed assumptions and appears determined to keep going down a road that has already demonstrably failed to deliver.

Unfortunately its attitude towards accountability for its actions in this area is also cause for concern.

Last month’s meeting of scrutiny councillors voted to establish a permanent committee called a “standing overview group” to oversee Exeter net zero delivery.

Labour chair Rob Hannaford emphasised the importance and value of this ongoing formal monitoring mechanism, the creation of which had been suggested by Green councillor Tess Read.

He proposed the motion himself, which was seconded by Conservative councillor Andrew Leadbetter.

Rob Hannaford and Karime Hassan at Exeter City Council's June 2022 strategic scrutiny committee meeting Rob Hannaford and Karime Hassan at the city council’s June strategic scrutiny committee meeting

But when council CEO Karime Hassan subsequently reported to the council’s executive committee, he omitted to mention the vote, instead saying: “Members called for an ongoing role in looking at the body of work and would seek to make this point to the scrutiny programme board”.

(Like other council bodies, this board meets in private without publishing its decisions, which it refers to the council’s strategic management board on which Mr Hassan sits.)

Not only is this not what the meeting of scrutiny councillors decided, it appears to frustrate their legal powers to act as a “check and balance on the executive”.

These are the same powers the council denied to scrutiny councillors when it controversially, and apparently unlawfully, decided to send Mr Hassan and another senior director to work for Exeter City Futures.

Mr Hassan’s report to the executive also failed to mention Councillor Read’s request for an Exeter greenhouse gas emissions monitoring report to be published annually so the city’s decarbonisation progress could be better understood.

In a written response, which was not published until several weeks after the meeting was held, he said doing so would have “resourcing implications”. He also said that Exeter City Futures does not have the capacity to do this, adding to the lengthening list of the company’s limitations as a decarbonisation delivery vehicle.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

At the same time Mr Hassan inserted several recommendations into his report that he had not mentioned at the meeting of scrutiny councillors.

One was for the council to make an “immediate and concerted effort” to concentrate on the delivery of a new district heat network despite acknowledging elsewhere in his report that “many hundreds of thousands of pounds” had been spent on failed attempts to implement such networks in the city centre and at the South West Exeter extension.

Another was to “invite Exeter City Futures to reflect on the challenges of resourcing the step change in activity to meet the net zero 2030 goal and to suggest options for meeting these challenges”, a proposal he said was particularly important, suggesting that the company would need “an enhanced resource commensurate to the challenge in hand”.

There were several more. Nothing was said about possible conflicts of interest arising around Mr Hassan’s proposal as council chief executive for the council to commission the services of a private company of which he is also chief executive.

Nor was anything said about his participation in scrutiny and executive decision-making meetings which directly addressed the company’s role.

The executive committee also noted, without comment, that Mr Hassan, who was until recently both CEO and a director of both Exeter City Council and Exeter City Futures, had unilaterally decided to appoint Labour councillor Zion Lights to the company’s board using powers he acquired in February 2016 which have not been examined since.

Good journalism costs money

The only way to cover the cost of producing and publishing independent public interest journalism is by readers helping to pay for it.

Each of Exeter Observer's paying subscribers keeps us up and running for one day each year by chipping in less than £2/week.

Our members contribute more towards our running costs and get more in return.

136 of the 300 readers we need as paying subscribers have signed up so far, which keeps us going until the middle of May each year.

If you think Exeter needs this kind of journalism then help us cover our costs all year round by joining them today.

Upgrade to paid

More stories
Illustrative view of proposed co-living blocks from Heavitree Road

Heavitree Road police station student accommodation and “co-living” scheme consultation extended

Developers revise application for full planning permission for 813-bed seven-block complex submitted in May as similar proposals proliferate across city centre.

Boneyard arcade games

Unique retro games arcade to create new Sidwell Street venue after long search

Boneyard arcade seeking permission to change use of empty Brighthouse retail unit after making way for “co-living” block at previous Red Lion Lane location.

Proposed revised Mary Arches Bartholomew Street East co-living block elevation

Mary Arches “co-living” developer resists “miniscule” room size criticisms as design revisions prompt further consultation

Changes include increased building footprints and removal of twelve rooms to provide eleven communal kitchens – between residents of 297 studios – while gates obstruct pedestrian thoroughfare and site’s historic setting and significance essentially ignored.

September 2025 permitted replacement scheme west elevation

Council denies data and contrives criteria to dismiss community balance concerns in third King Billy student block approval

Exeter Observer analysis finds more students living in city centre than residents as council bid to include PBSA in housing delivery figures weakens local planning policy – but does not remove it from decision-making altogether.

, updated

Grace Road Fields in March

Botched consultation restarted on sale of 8.5 acres of Riverside Valley Park green space

Council land disposal to include rights to lay underground distribution pipework across River Exe floodplain following “low-to-zero carbon” Grace Road Fields heat plant planning approval in face of Environment Agency sequential test concerns.

On Our Radar
Jo Eades

FRIDAY 31 OCTOBER 2025

Spork! Dead Poets Slam 2025

Halloween spoken-word special featuring Jo Eades and Samuel L. Cohen with a £100 cash prize poetry slam.

EXETER PHOENIX

Carmen with rose graphic

SATURDAY 8 & SATURDAY 22 NOVEMBER 2025

Carmen

Exeter Opera Group performs Bizet’s tale of a free-spirited woman and her passionate and destructive love affair with a soldier.

EXETER CASTLE

Exeter Philharmonic Choir

SATURDAY 8 NOVEMBER 2025

The Weather Book

Exeter Philharmonic Choir performs a new weather-inspired work plus pieces by Brahms, Poulenc and Ralph Vaughan Williams.

EXETER CATHEDRAL