Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work from less than £2/week

Upgrade to paid
FEATURES

Exeter’s first “zero carbon” housing development includes 96 car parking spaces for 40 homes

Exeter City Council has approved plans to develop land at Pinhoe with a parking ratio of 2.4 cars per household as part of an “exemplar scheme for future residential development in the city” while accepting that zero carbon construction comes “at a cost to the provision of affordable housing”.

Martin Redfern with Daniel Clark, Local Democracy Reporter

In what may be an indication of development decisions to come, Exeter City Council planning committee approved plans for 40 new “zero carbon” homes on Monday night despite previously deferring the decision due to concerns about the development’s impact on congestion levels and the low proportion of affordable housing included in the scheme.

The proposal to develop the 3.9 acre greenfield site between Pulling Road and Church Hill in Pinhoe initially included 100 car parking spaces, but a council report recommended a reduction to a total of 96 spaces, including two car ports and fourteen garages which Devon County Council, acting as local highway authority, does not count as parking spaces.

Were the 12,000 homes envisaged as part of the “Liveable Exeter” development plan delivered with the same ratio of 2.4 car parking spaces per household an additional 28,800 cars would join the city’s roads.

The Pulling Road proposal also initially included six affordable homes, just 15% of the total, but was amended to include six units for social rent and four for discounted market sale. Exeter City Council’s policy is that 35% of new developments should be affordable but the ten units included in the revised proposal amounted to only 25% of the total.

However the council’s inability to demonstrate a five year supply of deliverable housing sites means that a presumption in favour of development applies. Following viability assessment which included consideration of the higher construction costs of high-tech energy efficient housing and the presumption that developers of such dwellings should expect a 20% gross profit margin, council officers recommended approval of the plans.

Officers acknowledged that this form of development “results in a reduction in affordable housing provision” but said this was “an acceptable compromise which will result in both additional dwellings to meet the five year housing supply and a housing product which meets the overall aims of the council commitment toward being carbon neutral.”

Pulling Road Pinhoe Exeter zero carbon housing development site aerial photo Pulling Road development site aerial photo

City councillors nevertheless questioned the plans, expressing surprise that the county highways authority had not objected in a consultation reply which included a transport assessment that predicted a vehicle arriving at or leaving the site every 75 seconds during peak times.

A statement supporting the application said the new housing would generate “one vehicle trip every two minutes travelling in or out of the site on average”, a total of 720 movements a day which it described as “a minimal volume of vehicle flows”.

But the county council simply requested a £130,000 contribution from the developer towards its Pinhoe area access strategy in response.

Councillor Amal Ghusain said: “I don’t understand the logic behind highways allowing this to go ahead” and council leader Phil Bialyk said: “I don’t think it is satisfactory and will increase traffic quite a lot. I don’t get how highways have reached the decision that it is OK.”

Local residents also expressed concern at the impact of increasing vehicle congestion in the area, identifying “tremendous pressure” on existing roads and at pinch points including Cheynegate Lane and the junction of Church Hill and Harrington Lane.

Pulling Road Pinhoe Exeter zero carbon housing development location plan Pulling Road development site location plan

Local councillor Duncan Wood said Pinhoe had seen many developments which might not have had significant impact on traffic on their own, but which had aggregated to the point where traffic flow had increased significantly.

He said: “This seems to be a development to be achieved at any cost, irrespective of whether it can be safely accessed or the traffic can be absorbed on a network already beyond capacity.”

Fellow ward councillor Trish Oliver added: “We suffer from increasing traffic congestion and decreasing air quality and this will be exacerbated by all the other developments.”

The adjacent Home Farm development of 120 houses is under construction, and 380 more homes are due alongside the proposal site at Pinhoe Quarry.

But Rachel Sutton, city council portfolio holder for climate and culture, said that while the committee might disagree with the highways advice, there weren’t any reasons to refuse the scheme on such grounds.

She said: “There is a lot to like about this. The quality of the houses is commendable and I like zero carbon homes as that is what we need. This is finely balanced but I am broadly in favour.”

Councillor Keith Sparkes added: “We need the zero carbon homes in Exeter. Opposing on the traffic isn’t going to work, so this should go ahead.”

Pulling Road Pinhoe Exeter zero carbon housing development site plan Pulling Road development site plan

When the planning committee considered the application in February, Pinhoe councillor David Harvey pointed at the nearby bus service and cycle route and suggested the site was ripe for a car-free development.

And the developer’s application statement said: “The site is surrounded by an excellent pedestrian and cycle network which links the site with the neighbouring employment and residential areas.

“The city centre can be easily reached by cycle trips via a network of cycleways and advisory cycle routes.

“There are seven bus stops located within a 450 metre radius of the site which support a total of five different bus services.”

But Tom Carr, co-founder of developer Verto Homes, said making the site car-free would hinder sales.

“When spending money on a property, people want to be able to store a car. As much as we want to push towards zero carbon, we cannot dictate how people live their lives.

“We aim to build homes in a sustainable and environmentally friendly way. If Exeter is to lead the way and be carbon neutral, then supporting a zero carbon development is essential.”

Pulling Road Pinhoe Exeter zero carbon housing development design illustration Pulling Road development design illustration

The UK Green Building Council’s framework outlines what net zero carbon means in terms of building construction, operation and whole life emissions.

It says that the production and construction of residential buildings accounts for more than half their carbon impacts, and that carbon offsets are necessary to mitigate both direct and indirect emissions from their development and use.

And UK Advertising Standard Authority guidance requires that carbon reduction claims must be based on the full life cycle of products unless they state otherwise, and must make clear the limits of that life cycle.

The developer’s application statement says that the development could be Exeter’s “first genuine zero carbon housing scheme”.

But externalities such as emissions from motor vehicle journeys, remotely-generated electricity and the energy embedded in construction materials and their use all contribute to the overall impact of any development.

The application statement does not mention these impacts nor whether they will be offset.

And while infrastructure to enable the installation of electric vehicle charging points will be included in the development, there is no commitment to install charging points, nor any restriction on combustion engine-powered cars parking in the development’s 96 spaces.

The developer’s agent described the suggestion by a planning committee member that the provision for charging points should be increased as an “over-specification”, partly because it would increase demand on the local electricity distribution grid.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

As transport is Exeter’s largest source of carbon emissions, and vehicle congestion its bane, permitting developments which provide 2.4 car parking spaces for every household is neither compatible with the city’s vision for the future nor its carbon reduction plans.

And if private property development profits necessarily make energy efficient housing unaffordable, the city faces many prospective decisions in which it will have to choose whether schemes such as this do more to help meet its overall aims than hinder them.

As councillor Greg Sheldon said when the planning committee considered the Pulling Road application in February, with some houses expected to sell for more than £500,000: “It is no good saying we are getting zero carbon homes for the masses, if the masses can’t afford them.”

The deferred planning decision was approved by nine votes to three, with one abstention.

Independent, investigative, in the public interest

Exeter Observer publishes the journalism our local democracy needs: independent, investigative and in the public interest.

It can do this because it is the city's only news organisation that doesn't have to answer to advertisers, remote shareholders or those in power.

Instead, its not-for-profit business model is simple.

It depends on readers like you to sustain our reporting by contributing a small amount each month.

Lots of people currently chip in like this, but it's not enough to cover our costs. We need more paying subscribers to continue publishing.

127 of the 300 readers we need have signed up so far. Help us reach our goal by joining them today, if you haven't already.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription from less than £2/week to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

Upgrade to paid

More stories
Exeter College and Petroc campuses map

Exeter College and Petroc merger set to create largest college group in South West

Colleges hold public consultation on creation of new organisation which they say would educate 16,000 students at Exeter and North Devon campuses and employ 2,000 staff with £100 million turnover.

Proposed Clarendon House student block aerial view

Proposals to replace Clarendon House with 297-bed student accommodation complex submitted for approval

Developer Zinc Real Estate arrives at final proposal for up to ten storey Paris Street roundabout redevelopment after nearly two years of informal public consultations and meetings with city councillors and officers.

Nadder Park Road application site location map

Barley Lane greenfield plans place persistent threat to Exeter’s north and north-west hills in spotlight

Council inability to identify sufficient land to meet government housing delivery targets leaves residents with faint hope of local plan policies preventing Nadder Park Road ridgeline development despite 175 public objections to scheme.

Exeter City Council 2024-25 unaudited statement of accounts cover image

Unaudited 2024-25 city council accounts published for annual inspection period

Special information access rights enabling residents to examine records apply until 6 October after asset revaluation delayed publication from 1 July to 26 August.

Illustrative elevation of proposed student block in Summerland Street, Exeter

Pre-application feedback sought on proposals for six storey Summerland Street student accommodation block

Redevelopment of Unit 1 nightclub and Best Tyre Auto Centre in Verney Street would add 180 beds to 1,575 student bedspaces in immediate area on top of 145 studios in consented but unbuilt Summerland Street “co-living” block.

, updated

Former Bramdean School playing field

McCarthy Stone set to build 36 retirement flats on Heavitree school playing field

Proposals prompting concerns about loss of green space and adverse impact on historic character of conservation area follow redevelopment of former Bramdean School in Homefield Road.

On Our Radar
Burnet Patch Bridge spanning an eighteenth century cut in Exeter City Walls

FRIDAY 12 TO SUNDAY 21 SEPTEMBER 2025

Heritage Open Days 2025

Annual festival returns with free talks, tours and exhibitions at heritage sites in and around Exeter.

EXETER CITY CENTRE

Exeter Phoenix building

FRIDAY 12 SEPTEMBER TO SATURDAY 1 NOVEMBER 2025

Exeter Contemporary Open 2025

Annual exhibition featuring fifteen contemporary visual artists from across the UK.

EXETER PHOENIX

Two Moors Festival musicians performing

WEDNESDAY 1 TO SUNDAY 12 OCTOBER 2025

Two Moors Festival

Chamber music festival celebrates 25th anniversary with performances, talks and workshops across fifteen venues.

DARTMOOR, EXMOOR & SURROUNDS