NEWS

Howell Road garage for sale a week after student block redevelopment plans granted at appeal

Developer denied he would “spin in and spin out and take my profit” at planning committee that approved “backstop” plans for nine flats on site, saying student block was “what we want to build”.

Martin Redfern

A Howell Road garage has been put up for sale just seven days after a planning inspector overturned a city council decision to refuse planning permission for redevelopment of the site as a 26-bed student accommodation block.

The guide price for the 0.13 acre site in St James, where outline permission for an apparently identical block of nine flats has also been approved, is £675,000. It is described as a “prime investment location” close to the university’s Streatham campus.

In response to councillors’ criticism of his approach at the planning committee meeting that granted permission for the flats last September, developer Sam Williams said he thought it was “a bit disingenuous to say I’m going to spin in and spin out and take my profit”.

When asked to confirm whether his application for permission to build the flats was in good faith he said “we’ll build the residential scheme” only if the appeal against the student block refusal failed, adding that the student accommodation block was “what we want to build”.

Howell Road garage student block illustrative elevation Howell Road garage student block illustrative elevation.
Source: Exeter City Council.

The application to redevelop the garage site for student accommodation prompted significant local opposition when it was submitted two years ago.

It was refused in March last year on community balance grounds, as well over half the residential property in St James is already occupied by students.

The planning inspector’s decision to overturn the refusal concluded that the application complied with the St James Neighbourhood Plan, which aims to improve the social balance of this part of the city by restricting new student accommodation development.

Exeter St James Community Trust described the decision as “not only extremely disappointing, but baffling”.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

The appeal decision suggests that the plan’s definition of “community balance” – a diverse population which includes people at all stages of their lives and which is not dominated by a single group – is less relevant in this case as the applicable policy did not explicitly mention purpose built student accommodation.

It also says that the area around the Howell Road garage “is not predominantly characterised by intact streets of traditional residential development” because the garage itself is not residential and there is a brick wall opposite and another along the road.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
Northbrook swimming pool

City council holds sham Northbrook swimming pool closure consultation

£600,000 Exeter Leisure services budget cut signed off two weeks before pool consultation opened as St Sidwell’s Point drains other council leisure sites.

Met Office building at Exeter Science Park

Met Office to sell Exeter Science Park supercomputer and office buildings

Disposal motivated by replacement of nine year-old supercomputer with £1.2 billion government-funded off-site Microsoft facility.

St Petrock's outreach workers with a rough sleeper

Annual city council rough sleeper count “consistently underestimates” extent of Exeter rough sleeping

Homelessness charity St Petrock’s calls on council to change count methodology which identifies fewer rough sleepers than those known by outreach workers and reflected in government figures.

Devon County Council budget meeting 20 February 2025

Devon County Council reveals perilous financial state with SEND spending having “significant impact” on cash balances

5.9% budget increase for 2025-26 conceals £22 million cuts and £66 million cost increases with “inevitable” impact on “vital” services.

Grace Road Fields March 2025

Exeter Energy insists Riverside Valley Park only viable heat plant site but fails to explain Marsh Barton brownfield rejection

Company admits River Exe water source connection merely “potential” after 2036, incinerator connection only “possible” after 2030 and solar array “will not” meet plant electricity demand while statutory objections challenge Grace Road Fields plans.

Exeter Community Lottery revenue distribution FAQ

Exeter Community Lottery income spent on gambling licence fees and costs despite council marketing and point of sale claims

Materially misleading claims that 60% of ticket sales revenue goes to good causes repeatedly made on lottery website and in official council communications as Australian multinational profits from local voluntary and community sector support.

On Our Radar
Titus Andronicus by Nicholas Rowe

THURSDAY 3 APRIL 2025

Titus Andronicus

Lightbear Lane hosts a reading of Shakespeare’s bloody revenge tale.

ST NICHOLAS PRIORY

Jess Hughes Cameron and Chin See at 2024 Topsham Music Festival

FRIDAY 25 TO SUNDAY 27 APRIL 2025

2025 Topsham Music Festival

Three day event features jazz, percussion and classical music played by young professional musicians from across the country.

TOPSHAM

Edward Tripp

TUESDAY 29 APRIL 2025

City Slam 2025

Exeter City of Literature, Taking the Mic and Spork! co-host a third city-wide spoken-word poetry competition.

EXETER PHOENIX