COMMENT

County council to impose new local government tier despite majority opposition to devolution deal

Emptiness of claims that new combined authority will be accountable reflected in failure to respect consultation results as all eight Devon district councils decry prospective democratic deficit.

Martin Redfern

Devon County Council is set to impose a new tier of local government despite the results of a public consultation that found majority opposition to its plans.

The Devon and Torbay devolution deal will take away control of housing and prosperity funding from Devon’s district councils, which include Exeter City Council, and move transport policy powers out of reach by creating a new, unelected local authority.

The deal comes with just £16 million of new funding, which amounts to £16.77 for each of the 953,800 people who will live under the newly-created Devon & Torbay Combined County Authority. The government will retain control over both the funding and the new combined authority’s delivery plans.

The county council was obliged to hold a public consultation on the draft deal, and consider its results, which show a majority of respondents disagree, strongly disagree or oppose the deal. The consultation also recorded widespread criticism of the proposed new combined authority governance and delivery arrangements in particular.

The county council cabinet ignored this outcome when it met yesterday, recommending instead that a special meeting of all Devon county councillors, to be held next Monday, should ratify the deal and submit it to central government for approval.

Maria Price, county solicitor, claimed that the consultation responses had been “fully considered” but said the exercise had only been about “engagement”.

Devon County Council Cabinet meeting on 22 April 2024 at County Hall Devon County Council Cabinet meeting on 22 April 2024 at County Hall

A cabinet report by county council chief executive Donna Manson says “unanimous support for the proposal is not a prerequisite to moving forward”, but it does not address whether majority support should instead be.

It admits that a “large proportion” of the consultation responses, in particular those of Devon’s eight district councils, had expressed concerns about the governance of the new combined authority, with a “significant number” making points about democratic representation and decision-making.

However it fails to reconcile the contradiction between its claim that the devolution deal would not impose top-down restructuring of local government with the restructuring that the deal entails and which the county council is set to impose on Whitehall’s behalf.

It also suggests that the proposed advisory groups, which have been extended to include voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations as well as health care providers and commissioners, would enable partnership working with the new authority, although they would not have any decision-making powers if they were established, which is not guaranteed.

It does not acknowledge that, should these groups end up as anything other than window dressing, they would constitute yet another unaccountable shadow governance mechanism, increasing the democratic deficit that comes with the combined authority either way.

The report also claims that the area covered by the devolution deal, which includes Devon and Torbay but not Plymouth, which pulled out of negotiations last year on principle, constitutes a “coherent economic area” simply by dint of its population and because it contains “a range of business sectors and a strategic transport network”. No economic geographer would recognise this.

It also admits that much of the detail related to the new combined authority’s governance and decision-making will not be dealt with until after the fact, with whichever government is in power by then calling the shots.

Devon County Council Devon and Torbay Devolution deal consultation results Devon County Council Devon and Torbay devolution deal consultation results

An accompanying consultation feedback report makes clear the extent of opposition to the deal, and that many of those who responded supportively appear not to have realised just how limited is the funding with which it comes.

It also employs well-worn subterfuges to obscure the survey findings, grouping together responses to questions asked separately to disguise their distribution and rounding percentages in favour of the county council’s preferred outcomes.

Survey respondents were asked to choose on a Lickert scale but instead of presenting the numbers of people who strongly agreed with each proposal separately from the numbers who merely agreed, and the numbers who strongly disagreed from those who merely disagreed, it lumped them together.

So when it says that 338 respondents agreed or strongly agreed with the deal’s skills proposals, and 351 disagreed or strongly disagreed, it isn’t possible to tell whether the responses tilted more strongly one way or another, only that more people didn’t like the proposals than did.

It nevertheless describes this crude distribution as “broadly evenly split”, perhaps because it rounds up the percentage in favour and rounds down the percentage against to present the difference between the two figures as 1% when it is actually much closer to 2%.

Other similarly specious survey results presentations follow. But the county council elects not to present numeric comparisons of the distributions of respondents’ comments at all. Perhaps this is because they are decisively against the proposals on six of the eight issues about which consultation questions were asked.

Governance tops the opposition charts on both metrics, with 48% against and only 36% in favour on Lickert scale responses and 65% against and only 35% in favour on comment responses.

Overall, while some individual survey questions yielded a balance in support, the responses against the proposals were decisively more numerous than those in favour.

Devon & Torbay Combined County Authority governance structure diagram Devon & Torbay Combined County Authority governance structure. Only the “constituent” members vote and make decisions. Source: Devon County Council.

All eight of Devon’s district councils also raised governance as a major concern in their consultation responses.

Exeter City Council said the legislation underpinning the new combined authority “creates a democratic deficit for all district councils” and that Torbay, with fewer residents than several Devon districts but three voting seats on the new authority when the districts have none, is “afforded disproportionate and inequitable democratic input” by the deal.

Mid Devon District Council said it was hard to know whether the failure to include the county’s housing authorities in the new governance arrangements while acknowledging housing challenges as among the most pressing issues facing the area indicates “dereliction or incompetence”.

It was among several who pointed out what it called “the policy paradox of government devolution diminishing the voice of local democratic institutions”. South Hams District Council added that the “proposed combined authority’s remoteness and lack of democratic accountability, including the lack of voting rights for district councils, further disqualifies it from being described as devolution”.

Caroline Leaver, who leads the Liberal Democrat opposition at County Hall and also sits on North Devon Council, told yesterday’s cabinet meeting that it was striking that all of Devon’s district councils agreed that the deal, which she described as a “power grab”, would result in a democratic deficit.

Carol Whitton, who leads the Labour county council group, said she was concerned residents would not experience the governance changes as devolution despite the county council’s attempts to present them this way.

Julian Brazil, who is also South Hams District Council leader, pointed out that the control government would retain over the £16 million funding which is attached to the deal clearly confirmed it could not be called devolution.

He then added that the new government would take a very different view of the situation when it came to power, instead favouring Plymouth as the region’s most significant economic actor.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

County council leader John Hart, the deal’s midwife, who recently announced he is to step down after running Devon County Council for the past fifteen years, said he believed it would significantly change Whitehall’s view of Devon.

He added that the county was “already being talked about in London differently by some junior ministers” after negotiations with civil servants around its SEND deficit deal.

No other member of the Conservative cabinet spoke during the meeting, which approved the deal unanimously. It will come before a special meeting of all Devon county councillors, to be held next Monday, for ratification, and is expected to come into force by the autumn.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
2024-25 Devon County Council locality budget community grants allocations by Exeter councillor

Heavitree & Whipton Barton community groups miss out on £14,600 after Danny Barnes fails to sign funding agreements

Voluntary sector grants now lost following 12% councillor attendance record highlighting need for by-elections in absentee cases.

Suspended Devon and Cornwall Police Chief Constable Will Kerr

Criminal investigation into suspended Devon & Cornwall Police Chief Constable dropped

Will Kerr to remain suspended while IOPC resumes previously paused conduct investigation and interim chief constable James Vaughan continues to lead force.

2024 duration in hours of monitored spill events at water company overflow sites bar graph

South West Water bills rise by a third following worst performance in sector with 550,000 hours of sewage spills

Tariffs increase as Environment Agency publishes damning data after South West Water owner Pennon Group issues £24.5 million in dividends to shareholders.

Devon & Torbay Combined County Authority inaugural meeting 19 March 2025

Devon & Torbay CCA sets sail for regional democratic deficit with £500,000 crew

Combined county authority throws public accountability overboard as future regional strategic governance body ratifies constitution at inaugural meeting but fails to explain why so many staff needed to deliver so little at such colossal cost.

Exeter Post Office in Guildhall Shopping Centre WHSmith

Sidwell Street Post Office to close as WHSmith shops sale raises risk of Exeter city centre counter service disappearance

Closure follows loss of Exeter’s last Crown Post Office in Bedford Street, since when all city branches operated by franchisees or independent businesses.

Exeter local elections campaign materials

Help hold Devon’s political parties and politicians to account during the 2025 local elections

Send us any campaign materials you receive so we can fact-check candidates’ claims and hold them to their pledges after the votes have been counted.

On Our Radar
Jess Hughes Cameron and Chin See at 2024 Topsham Music Festival

FRIDAY 25 TO SUNDAY 27 APRIL 2025

2025 Topsham Music Festival

Three day event features jazz, percussion and classical music played by young professional musicians from across the country.

TOPSHAM

Tabatha Andrews sculpture

SATURDAY 26 APRIL TO SATURDAY 21 JUNE 2025

The Slightest Gesture

Sculptor and installation artist Tabatha Andrews presents a new immersive exhibition.

EXETER PHOENIX

Liberation in Venice 1945

SUNDAY 27 APRIL 2025

Festa Di Liberazione

Italian Cultural Association Exeter hosts a day of music, dance, poetry and Italian culture.

KALEIDER

Edward Tripp

TUESDAY 29 APRIL 2025

City Slam 2025

Exeter City of Literature, Taking the Mic and Spork! co-host a third city-wide spoken-word poetry competition.

EXETER PHOENIX

Exeter Pride in Exeter High Street

SATURDAY 10 MAY 2025

Exeter Pride 2025

Exeter Pride returns for a celebration of LGBTQ+ diversity with a parade, marketplace, music, cabaret and more.

NORTHERNHAY GARDENS

Detail from Panorama of Prague from the Schönborn Garden

SATURDAY 10 MAY 2025

Czech Classics

Isca Ensemble and chorus perform a programme by Czech composer Antonín Dvořák.

EXETER CATHEDRAL