Independent, investigative, in the public interest  Upgrade to paid

NEWS

Heavitree Road police station and magistrates court redevelopment appeal dismissed

Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner and offshore development partner sent back to drawing board after attempt to overturn city council decision to refuse two huge student/co-living blocks fails.

Martin Redfern

Exeter City Council’s decision to refuse planning permission for a student and co-living development on the site of the former police station and magistrates court in Heavitree Road has been upheld by a planning inspector at appeal.

The application for outline planning permission (with all matters considered in detail except landscaping) was eventually refused in February last year after eight design iterations, six council meetings and four rounds of public consultation had considered it over the course of nearly three years.

The development had been enthusiastically recommended by city council development director Ian Collinson who said its extreme residential densities would align with the council’s Liveable Exeter vision.

However local councillors and residents objected to the scheme for a wide range of reasons. These included the adverse impact of its scale, mass and siting, the insufficient residential amenity space it provided, the harm it would do to the surrounding area and the loss of 26 trees on the site.

Illustrative elevation of proposed development facing St Luke's campus Illustrative elevation of proposed development facing St Luke’s campus

Joint developers the office of the Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner and offshore-registered PBSA Heavitree Road S.A.R.L. sought to overturn the decision at appeal in September last year. A five-day hearing took place just before Christmas.

Amended plans submitted before the appeal clarified that the total number of units proposed in the development after further changes were made to the building designs was 955, nine fewer than the 964 units that had been refused.

The council and the appellants reached agreement over a range of issues relating to the development both before and during the hearing.

As a result, the inspector’s decision focussed on its prospective impact on the character and appearance of the area, including on St Luke’s College buildings on the university campus opposite, and on the privacy and outlook of neighbouring residents in Higher Summerlands to the west.

Illustrative aerial view of proposed development from south east Illustrative aerial view of proposed development from south east

The inspector said the proposed buildings would appear as “vastly larger than any other nearby building”, including The Gorge, the neighbouring block described as “student accommodation”, and “would be of immense proportions compared to anything surrounding them”.

The inspector added that while the council seeks what it calls “transformational change” on the development site, this phrase can be interpreted in several ways, and that “it would be perverse for that interpretation to mean introducing a development at odds with its context as that approach would not accord with the principles of good design required by local and national planning policy”.

He also said the proposal “goes beyond what is acceptable in terms of the density, grain and overall character of its surroundings” and would be “unacceptably strident” in a predominantly suburban residential area, although he found it would not be harmful to the historic significance of the St Luke’s College building opposite.

He added that the development site’s distance from Heavitree Road roundabout suggested that the claim that the scheme would create a gateway to Exeter city centre would be “a gateway in the wrong place”.

The inspector nevertheless found that the outlook and privacy for residents in Higher Summerlands would not be materially different as a result of the scheme, partly because their main focus is away from the development site towards their larger rear gardens and street access.

Development site boundary beside Higher Summerlands residential housing Development site boundary beside Higher Summerlands residential housing

Significant changes to the National Planning Policy Framework to which planning decisions must adhere were made immediately after the appeal hearing concluded, which meant that the council no longer had to demonstrate a supply of specific development sites that are sufficient to meet government-set housing delivery targets for the following five years.

The reduced requirement for four years’ housing land supply, and the council’s current ability to demonstrate it, means that planning decisions in the city are now not skewed favour of approval as they had been for several years.

The inspector said that this reduced requirement does not diminish the value of development proposals that provide new housing, particularly as housing delivery targets are, in any case, a minimum.

However he concluded that, these potential benefits notwithstanding, the scheme would be “overly-assertive and incongruous”, would “cross the line of acceptability in terms of its effects on the local area” and would cause harm to the area’s character and appearance that would be “severe”.

Independent, investigative, in the public interest

Exeter Observer publishes the independent investigative journalism our local democracy needs.

It can do this because it is the city's only news organisation that doesn't have to answer to corporate advertisers, remote shareholders or those in power.

Instead, its not-for-profit public interest business model is simple.

It depends on readers like you to sustain our reporting by contributing a small amount each month.

Lots of people currently chip in like this, but it's not enough to cover our costs. We need more paying subscribers to keep publishing.

135 of the 300 readers we need have signed up so far. Help us reach our goal by joining them today.

Support our work from less than £2/week and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

Upgrade to paid

More stories
Boneyard arcade games

Unique retro games arcade to create new Sidwell Street venue after long search

Boneyard arcade seeking permission to change use of empty Brighthouse retail unit after making way for “co-living” block at previous Red Lion Lane location.

Proposed revised Mary Arches Bartholomew Street East co-living block elevation

Mary Arches “co-living” developer resists “miniscule” room size criticisms as design revisions prompt further consultation

Changes include increased building footprints and removal of twelve rooms to provide eleven communal kitchens – between residents of 297 studios – while gates obstruct pedestrian thoroughfare and site’s historic setting and significance essentially ignored.

September 2025 permitted replacement scheme west elevation

Council denies data and contrives criteria to dismiss community balance concerns in third King Billy student block approval

Exeter Observer analysis finds more students living in city centre than residents as council bid to include PBSA in housing delivery figures weakens local planning policy – but does not remove it from decision-making altogether.

, updated

Grace Road Fields in March

Botched consultation restarted on sale of 8.5 acres of Riverside Valley Park green space

Council land disposal to include rights to lay underground distribution pipework across River Exe floodplain following “low-to-zero carbon” Grace Road Fields heat plant planning approval in face of Environment Agency sequential test concerns.

Proposed Clarendon House student block aerial view

Proposals to replace Clarendon House with 297-bed student accommodation complex submitted for approval

Developer Zinc Real Estate arrives at final proposal for up to ten storey Paris Street roundabout redevelopment after nearly two years of informal public consultations and meetings with city councillors and officers.

On Our Radar
Jo Eades

FRIDAY 31 OCTOBER 2025

Spork! Dead Poets Slam 2025

Halloween spoken-word special featuring Jo Eades and Samuel L. Cohen with a £100 cash prize poetry slam.

EXETER PHOENIX

Carmen with rose graphic

SATURDAY 8 & SATURDAY 22 NOVEMBER 2025

Carmen

Exeter Opera Group performs Bizet’s tale of a free-spirited woman and her passionate and destructive love affair with a soldier.

EXETER CASTLE

Exeter Philharmonic Choir

SATURDAY 8 NOVEMBER 2025

The Weather Book

Exeter Philharmonic Choir performs a new weather-inspired work plus pieces by Brahms, Poulenc and Ralph Vaughan Williams.

EXETER CATHEDRAL