FEATURES

Closed doors at County Hall for councillor conduct hearings

A survey of local authority approaches to standards committee hearings finds Devon County Council alone in imposing private determination of conduct complaints.

Martin Redfern with Peter Cleasby

When electors living in Exeter’s Alphington ward voted in this year’s local elections they did not know that their councillor, Yvonne Atkinson, who was standing for re-election, had been investigated by the police and found in breach of the county council members’ code of conduct for failing to disclose a pecuniary interest.

Had Devon County Council published the minutes of its March standards committee meeting in the week that followed the meeting, as is usual, many votes might have been cast differently. As it is, the county council did not publish them until four days after the election results were announced.

And what it did publish is only a cursory summary of a fourteen month process involving Devon & Cornwall Police and the Crown Prosecution Service.

The county council redacted all seventeen supporting documents containing 161 pages of correspondence that provide a complete account of what happened, including the decision not to prosecute, and which should be a matter of public record.

Devon County Council standards committee redacted documents

It is standard practice for complaints against local councillors to be first examined in private to see whether there is a case to answer. This approach protects individual councillors where the evidence is weak or non-existent.

It is only when council officers conclude that a councillor has almost certainly breached the code of conduct, usually in consultation with “independent persons” appointed to assist in such cases, that the issue is referred to a formal local authority standards committee to make a final decision.

At this point practice between councils diverges. We conducted a survey to assess how approaches to standards committee openness vary between local authorities.

We ensured a mix of council type by looking at county councils, district councils, metropolitan councils, unitary authorities and London boroughs, a total of 27 councils including all the district councils in Devon.

We reviewed each council’s constitution, its complaints protocols and the minutes of recent standards committee hearings where available, then categorised them in three groups according to their degree of openness around standards committee hearings.

Closed doors at County Hall Closed doors at County Hall

The top group includes councils which default to holding standards committee hearings in public unless there are exceptional reasons for them taking place in private.

Four of Devon’s second tier councils follow variations of this policy: Exeter City Council, East Devon and South Hams district councils and West Devon Borough Council.

Another nine councils in our sample also do so: Maidstone Borough Council, Essex, Hampshire and Lancashire county councils, the London Borough of Richmond upon Thames, Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council, South Tyneside Council, which is a metropolitan district, and the unitary authorities in Dorset and the East Riding of Yorkshire.

Two further councils have also adopted this policy but nevertheless tend to closed sessions: the London Borough of Haringey and Northumberland County Council.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

In the middle group are five councils which simply apply the normal rules about meetings privacy and make no presumption about standards committees either way.

These are Mid Devon, North Devon and Teignbridge district councils, Chesterfield Borough Council and Cornwall Council, which is a unitary authority.

Six further councils in our sample have also adopted this policy but nevertheless tend to closed sessions. These are Torridge District Council, Norwich City Council, Leicestershire County Council, Salford City Council, Wakefield Metropolitan District Council and Shropshire Council, a unitary authority.

There was only one council in the bottom group in our survey, that has an absolute rule requiring private assessment and determination of councillor conduct complaints: Devon County Council.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
Illustrative floor plan of new redevelopment proposals

New Heavitree Road police station student accommodation and “co-living” complex proposals submitted to Exeter City council

Application for full planning permission for 813-room scheme in seven blocks follows decision to reject previously-proposed 955-room scheme in two blocks which was subsequently upheld at appeal.

Danny Barnes

Danny Barnes received full £15,000 Devon County Council allowance during 2024-25

Heavitree & Whipton Barton councillor failed to sign off £14,600 community grants after attending only two of fifteen public meetings and is alleged to have worked for Scottish Labour MP Imogen Walker since shortly after last year’s general elections.

, updated

Exeter cycle route E9 Wonford Road bus gate modal filter

Wonford Road modal filter bus gate to be first of five Exeter ANPR camera sites

Devon County Council will use new moving traffic offence enforcement powers to issue penalty charge notices to motorists contravening active travel, bus lane and one-way street restrictions.

Devon five-a-day fruit & vegetable consumption by district 2023-24

Exeter residents eat lowest proportion of 5-a-day fruit and vegetables in Devon with only South Hams above England average

Public health report also finds three in ten Devon residents are physically inactive and nearly two-thirds overweight with new countywide health and well-being strategy due in autumn.

Save Northbrook Pool campaigners dressed in black outside Exeter City Council's offices on 24 June 2025

Labour councillors dive deeper into denial in decision to abandon Northbrook pool

Exeter residents mourn as council suppresses destructive consequences of creating St Sidwell’s Point complex that looms in leisure service shadows like a leviathan.

Devon & Torbay Combined County Authority draft local growth plan infographic

Devon & Torbay CCA keeps quiet about 2025-35 Local Growth Plan as it takes charge of regional development agenda

Combined County Authority privately selects unspecified stakeholders to co-author document setting out strategic priorities but with little of substance to say on addressing region’s structural challenges.

On Our Radar
St Thomas churchyard

SATURDAY 19 JULY 2025

Love St Thomas Summer Festival

New community event launches with live music, talks, workshops, stalls, refreshments and family-friendly activities.

ST THOMAS CHURCHYARD

Summer at the Quayside illustration

TUESDAY 29 JULY TO FRIDAY 29 AUGUST 2025

Summer at the Quayside

A month of free family activities including weaving, felting, doodling and drumming.

EXETER QUAY

Spork! summer special

THURSDAY 31 JULY TO THURSDAY 14 AUGUST 2025

Theatre in the Park

Exeter Phoenix hosts an al fresco summer theatre season featuring Shakespeare, spoken-word poetry, puppetry and physical comedy.

ROUGEMONT GARDENS