ANALYSIS DEMOCRACY & GOVERNANCE

Exeter City Living put council at 'significant financial risk' after £2.2 million loss in first two years

Missing business plan, lack of transparency and conflicts of interest among senior council directors prompt board resignations and governance review at council-owned and funded company.

Exeter city council Exeter city living Property development Housing crisis Accountability & transparency Freedom of information

Exeter City Council’s auditor has identified significant weaknesses in Exeter City Living governance arrangements that could lead to “significant loss or exposure to significant financial risk” for the council in relation to loans it approved to the company.

By the end of March last year the council had approved loans to the company totalling £24.6 million despite the company accumulating losses of £2.2 million in its first two years of trading.

The auditor’s report, which concerns the 2020-21 financial year, identifies governance weaknesses including the absence of a 2021-22 business plan for the council-owned and funded company, the council’s failure to require company performance reports, and conflicts of interest created by council directors with statutory legal and financial responsibilities holding company board roles.

The report is also critical of the council’s practice of taking all decisions related to the company in private and withholding company business plans and reports from the public.

Exeter City Council 2020-21 external audit report key recommendation

Exeter City Council 2020-21 external audit report key recommendation

The auditor issued a “key recommendation”, as required by the National Audit Office, setting out actions that the council should take where significant weaknesses in its financial arrangements have been identified, as well as nine related improvement recommendations.

A formal review of the council’s progress on making the required changes will take place next year, following an external review of the company’s governance arrangements that the council has now commissioned.

Two senior council directors have already resigned from the company’s board as well as the board of Exeter City Group, Exeter City Living’s parent company.

At a council meeting last week the auditor said that such recommendations were not issued lightly, adding that there was significant scope for the council to improve transparency in relation to the company, around its financial affairs in particular, so it could be held to account more effectively.

Exeter City Council 2020-21 external audit report key recommendation continued

Exeter City Council 2020-21 external audit report key recommendation (continued)

When Exeter City Living was created in July 2018 the late Pete Edwards, then council leader, confirmed that the council would make Exeter City Living business plans and reports publicly available with only limited, legally-compliant exceptions to cover commercially sensitive financial information.

However by the following year the council was routinely excluding the public from meetings which discuss Exeter City Living and withholding related information and documents.

Exeter Observer responded by systematically challenging the council’s Exeter City Living transparency failures using local government transparency and public information access rights.

We sought the release of company business plans and reports via freedom of information legislation, submitted formal objections to the council’s practice of making decisions about the company in private and exercised public accounts inspection rights to scrutinise the company’s financial affairs.

The council has persistently sought to evade scrutiny despite its statutory obligations, routinely taking months to reply to information requests then supplying extensively redacted documents without proper justification for non-disclosure.

It has repeatedly disputed the legislative basis for transparency in relation to private meetings and simply failed to respond to questions about the lawfulness of company operations.

The auditor’s recent report makes clear that its approach needs to change.

Exeter City Living 2020-21 business plan redactions Exeter City Living 2020-21 business plan redactions

When Exeter Observer examined all the council’s significant decisions regarding Exeter City Living earlier this year we found that most appeared to breach local government regulations intended to protect the public interest in the use of public land and money.

We also found decisions that were made without any scrutiny at all, including the decision not to produce a company 2021-22 business plan that was criticised in the auditor’s report.

This was taken in private by the council’s chief executive, Karime Hassan, in consultation with Dave Hodgson, the council’s financial director and section 151 officer – then also an Exeter City Living (and Exeter City Group) company director – and council leader Phil Bialyk.

It led directly to the situation criticised in the auditor’s report: not only were company financing and delivery assumptions not updated to reflect changing market conditions, including the impact of the pandemic, the council did not receive any progress reports in relation to the outdated business plan so was “not able to hold the company directors formally to account”.

Exeter City Living 2022-23 business plan redactions Exeter City Living 2022-23 business plan redactions

Karime Hassan also took the decisions that Exeter City Group would not pursue subsidiary consultancy or retrofit companies in private in April last year.

The council said the powers delegated to the company’s Shareholder Representative (a role he held from September 2020) were sufficient to have taken these decisions, but there does not appear to be any reference to such powers in the company management agreement delegation scheme.

When council officers asked us to raise our concerns about the council’s potential exposure to financial risk in writing, in detail, more than twelve months ago, we were told that the council’s monitoring officer, Baan Al-Khafaji, would investigate. We never received a reply.

However earlier this year she attended an executive meeting to advise it on its response to our objections to the council taking decisions about Exeter City Living in private.

She was also then a director of Exeter City Living (and Exeter City Group) and so legally required to act in the interests of the company despite her statutory role at the council, exactly the conflict of interest criticised in the auditor’s report.

Exeter City Living Vaughan Road development site Exeter City Living Vaughan Road development site

The council has so far allocated nearly £1 million to Exeter City Living for start up and planning costs, approved loans of nearly £25 million for development delivery, gifted it more than £2 million in land purchase discounts and commissioned or purchased just over £20 million of housing.

The company has also been granted more than £7 million of central government financial support, yet it has completed just 22 housing units in the four and a half years since it was created.

It has delivered so little that it is reduced to claiming credit for St. Sidwell’s Point leisure centre on its website alongside the marketing for its Clifton Hill and Vaughan Road developments, both of which have stalled.

Clifton Hill sports centre closed nearly five years ago but redevelopment hasn’t got past demolition, paid for by the government, with no prospect of further work until 2023-24 or beyond. Vaughan Road is in a similar state, with the site becoming a focus for anti-social behaviour.

The council nevertheless intends to appoint the company to redevelop Mary Arches multi-storey car park, making early use of another government demolition grant despite its delivery record.

Exeter City Council Mary Arches Street multi-storey car park Exeter City Council Mary Arches Street multi-storey car park

The auditor’s recent report only addresses the company’s activities to the end of March 2021. Important questions remain unanswered about what has happened since.

In June 2021 the council successfully applied for government funding to support development of a total of 461 dwellings on five Exeter City Living sites. Detailed viability assessments were included in its application which specified that three-quarters would be for market rent or sale despite the public procurement rules exemption eligibility requirement that no more than 20% of the company’s activity can be in the private sector.

This exemption is the basis on which the council decided, the following month, to commission the company to relocate its works facility at Belle Isle depot, with a budget of £3.5 million, without competitive tendering.

It is also the basis on which it decided, in September last year, to sell the depot to the company for redevelopment for £2.2 million. The council has also received £675,000 from the government to redevelop this site: its funding bid said 70% of the proposed housing units would be constructed for sale on the open market.

The company’s recent consultation on its plans for the site, which the council did not publicise, said nothing about this use of public land and money to provide so much private housing.

Exeter City Living’s financing and activities are of essential public interest both because residents and businesses are entitled to know what the council is doing with these resources and because the company could expose the council to significant risk, as the auditor has now confirmed.

In a recent review of major financial problems at councils in Croydon, Northampton and Nottingham, Exeter City Council’s auditor highlighted the risk of optimism bias in local authority management of public money and criticised council pursuit of political objectives without effective scrutiny.

It said these can lead to failures to understand the risks of embarking on complex, major projects without appropriate due diligence, and emphasised the value of decision-making scrutiny.

The auditor is due to report on the council’s performance during the 2021-22 financial year in January. Not only does this period cover unanswered questions about Exeter City Living, it brings significant issues around council governance arrangements and decision-making in relation to Exeter City Futures and Exeter Development Fund into focus too.



Recent headlines
Recent headlines
Stagecoach subsidiary operating companies 2022-23 pre-tax profits bar chart

Stagecoach South West posts largest losses in sector despite greatest growth in journey numbers

Liveable Exeter Placemaking Charter cover image

Liveable Exeter Placemaking Charter consultation skewed towards only one of five 'core tools'

Empty studios at The Gorge

The Gorge stands 70% empty nearly six months after opening as mounting council tax liability looms

Spruce Close & Celia Crescent development aerial view

City council approves plans for controversial greenfield site housing

Longbrook Street student accommodation block illustrative elevation

Top to bottom King Billy student block redesign waved through as minor variation to consented plans

St Bridget Nurseries illustrative layout

Judge quashes planning permission for 350 homes at St Bridget Nurseries in Old Rydon Lane

Recent stories
Stagecoach subsidiary operating companies 2022-23 pre-tax profits bar chart

ANALYSIS  ⁄  TRANSPORT & MOBILITY

Stagecoach South West posts largest losses in sector despite greatest growth in journey numbers

Lowest year on year revenue rise compounded by above average staffing costs increase as £2 bus fare cap continues to prop up passenger demand.

Liveable Exeter Placemaking Charter cover image

ANALYSIS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

Liveable Exeter Placemaking Charter consultation skewed towards only one of five 'core tools'

Private developers' forum and other major components of new charter not mentioned in council communications, but transparency and new 'culture of openness' to 'help build trust in the planning system' emphasised throughout.

Empty studios at The Gorge

COMMENT  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

The Gorge stands 70% empty nearly six months after opening as mounting council tax liability looms

Council development director claims developer interest demonstrates need for co-living in Exeter but works have yet to start on all other such schemes.

Spruce Close & Celia Crescent development aerial view

NEWS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

City council approves plans for controversial greenfield site housing

Key details remain unresolved including future ownership and management of green space and public access restrictions during construction period.

Longbrook Street student accommodation block illustrative elevation

ANALYSIS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

Top to bottom King Billy student block redesign waved through as minor variation to consented plans

Council throws out Design Review Panel interventions and reneges on commitment to planning committee while developers claim unauthorised destruction of protected medieval wall justified on safety grounds.

St Bridget Nurseries illustrative layout

NEWS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

Judge quashes planning permission for 350 homes at St Bridget Nurseries in Old Rydon Lane

High Court judgement finds city council did not properly discharge duties or take material considerations into account, council officer seriously misled planning committee and county council failed in statutory local highway authority role.

On Our Radar
More stories
Illustrative elevation facing St Luke's campus

NEWS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

Heavitree Road police station & magistrates court redevelopment appeal dismissed

Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner and offshore development partner sent back to drawing board after attempt to overturn city council decision to refuse two huge student/co-living blocks fails.

Exeter City Council allotment fees increases 2016 to 2024 line graph

ANALYSIS  ⁄  CLIMATE & ENVIRONMENT

Council plans huge allotment fees increases to claw back cash from 1,500 city gardeners and growers

Plot holders provided with incomplete picture as consultation held which does not comply with council's own charter and delayed scrutiny report that omits key survey findings suggests council aims to turn profit from allotment provision.

, updated

Devon electric vehicle charging strategy cover

ANALYSIS  ⁄  TRANSPORT & MOBILITY

Devon County Council adopts charging strategy that provides for only 20% of EVs it expects by 2030

Local ULEV ownership has risen rapidly in recent years but many more vehicles have joined county's roads as local transport area ULEV growth lags behind rest of country and Exeter motor vehicle numbers alone top 87,000.

Land Trust garden community development of 3,000 homes at Beaulieu, near Chelmsford

ANALYSIS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

Liveable Exeter 'garden city' branding is about government funding, not green space

New Exeter Local Plan policy 'principles' have little in common with historic vision revitalised for 21st century by TCPA for government programme, while consented Haven Banks scheme and proposed new town near Exeter Airport have even less.

Scrutiny Programme Board agenda extract 21 July 2022

SPECIAL REPORTS  ⁄  DEMOCRACY & GOVERNANCE

City council scrutiny board enabling illicit obstruction of democracy

Essential safeguard against misuse of power misdirected by Executive members and senior officers while backbench councillors persistently denied rights to examine high-risk schemes and citywide climate crisis response.

3D view of revised development proposal

NEWS  ⁄  PLANNING & PLACE

Student landlord submits new plans for Union Road HMO back garden block following appeal failure

Application for six bedroom, single storey purpose built student accommodation block made on site of refused ten bedroom, two storey scheme in garden of thirteen bedroom shared student house.

Spotlight
St Bridget Nurseries illustrative layout

Judge quashes planning permission for 350 homes at St Bridget Nurseries in Old Rydon Lane

High Court judgement finds city council did not properly discharge duties or take material considerations into account, council officer seriously misled planning committee and county council failed in statutory local highway authority role.

All topics

ACCOUNTABILITY & TRANSPARENCY ACCOUNTABILITY & TRANSPARENCY ACCOUNTABILITY & TRANSPARENCY   AIR QUALITY AIR QUALITY AIR QUALITY   COP26 COP26 COP26   COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19   CITYPOINT CITYPOINT CITYPOINT   CLIFTON HILL SPORTS CENTRE CLIFTON HILL SPORTS CENTRE CLIFTON HILL SPORTS CENTRE   CLIMATE CRISIS CLIMATE CRISIS CLIMATE CRISIS   CO-LIVING CO-LIVING CO-LIVING   COMMUNITY INFRASTRUCTURE LEVY COMMUNITY INFRASTRUCTURE LEVY COMMUNITY INFRASTRUCTURE LEVY   CONGESTION CONGESTION CONGESTION   COUNCIL TAX COUNCIL TAX COUNCIL TAX   CROWN ESTATE CROWN ESTATE CROWN ESTATE   CYCLING & WALKING CYCLING & WALKING CYCLING & WALKING   DEMOCRATIC DEFICIT DEMOCRATIC DEFICIT DEMOCRATIC DEFICIT   DEVON & CORNWALL POLICE DEVON & CORNWALL POLICE DEVON & CORNWALL POLICE   DEVON CARBON PLAN DEVON CARBON PLAN DEVON CARBON PLAN   DEVON COUNTY COUNCIL DEVON COUNTY COUNCIL DEVON COUNTY COUNCIL   DEVON PENSION FUND DEVON PENSION FUND DEVON PENSION FUND   EAST DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL EAST DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL EAST DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL   EXETER AIRPORT EXETER AIRPORT EXETER AIRPORT   EXETER CATHEDRAL EXETER CATHEDRAL EXETER CATHEDRAL   EXETER CHIEFS EXETER CHIEFS EXETER CHIEFS   EXETER CITY COUNCIL EXETER CITY COUNCIL EXETER CITY COUNCIL   EXETER CITY FUTURES EXETER CITY FUTURES EXETER CITY FUTURES   EXETER CITY LIVING EXETER CITY LIVING EXETER CITY LIVING   EXETER CLIMATE ACTION HUB EXETER CLIMATE ACTION HUB EXETER CLIMATE ACTION HUB   EXETER COLLEGE EXETER COLLEGE EXETER COLLEGE   EXETER CULTURE EXETER CULTURE EXETER CULTURE   EXETER DEVELOPMENT FUND EXETER DEVELOPMENT FUND EXETER DEVELOPMENT FUND   EXETER LIVE BETTER EXETER LIVE BETTER EXETER LIVE BETTER   EXETER LOCAL PLAN EXETER LOCAL PLAN EXETER LOCAL PLAN   EXETER PHOENIX EXETER PHOENIX EXETER PHOENIX   EXETER PRIDE EXETER PRIDE EXETER PRIDE   EXETER SCIENCE PARK EXETER SCIENCE PARK EXETER SCIENCE PARK   EXETER ST DAVID'S EXETER ST DAVID'S EXETER ST DAVID'S   EXETER CITY CENTRE EXETER CITY CENTRE EXETER CITY CENTRE   EXTINCTION REBELLION EXETER EXTINCTION REBELLION EXETER EXTINCTION REBELLION EXETER   FREEDOM OF INFORMATION FREEDOM OF INFORMATION FREEDOM OF INFORMATION   FRIDAYS FOR FUTURE EXETER FRIDAYS FOR FUTURE EXETER FRIDAYS FOR FUTURE EXETER   GENERAL ELECTIONS GENERAL ELECTIONS GENERAL ELECTIONS   GUILDHALL GUILDHALL GUILDHALL   HARLEQUINS HARLEQUINS HARLEQUINS   HEART OF THE SOUTH WEST LEP HEART OF THE SOUTH WEST LEP HEART OF THE SOUTH WEST LEP   HOUSING CRISIS HOUSING CRISIS HOUSING CRISIS   LGBTQIA+ LGBTQIA+ LGBTQIA+   LIBRARIES UNLIMITED LIBRARIES UNLIMITED LIBRARIES UNLIMITED   LIVEABLE EXETER PLACE BOARD LIVEABLE EXETER PLACE BOARD LIVEABLE EXETER PLACE BOARD   LIVEABLE EXETER LIVEABLE EXETER LIVEABLE EXETER   LOCAL INDUSTRIAL STRATEGY LOCAL INDUSTRIAL STRATEGY LOCAL INDUSTRIAL STRATEGY   LOCAL ELECTIONS LOCAL ELECTIONS LOCAL ELECTIONS   MAKETANK MAKETANK MAKETANK   MARSH BARTON MARSH BARTON MARSH BARTON   MET OFFICE MET OFFICE MET OFFICE   MID DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL MID DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL MID DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL   NET ZERO EXETER NET ZERO EXETER NET ZERO EXETER   NORTHERNHAY GARDENS NORTHERNHAY GARDENS NORTHERNHAY GARDENS   OXYGEN HOUSE OXYGEN HOUSE OXYGEN HOUSE   PARIS STREET PARIS STREET PARIS STREET   PARKING PARKING PARKING   PENINSULA TRANSPORT PENINSULA TRANSPORT PENINSULA TRANSPORT   PLANNING POLICY PLANNING POLICY PLANNING POLICY   PRINCESSHAY PRINCESSHAY PRINCESSHAY   PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT   PUBLIC CONSULTATION PUBLIC CONSULTATION PUBLIC CONSULTATION   PUBLIC HEALTH PUBLIC HEALTH PUBLIC HEALTH   PUBLIC PARKS PUBLIC PARKS PUBLIC PARKS   PUBLIC REALM PUBLIC REALM PUBLIC REALM   PUBLIC TRANSPORT PUBLIC TRANSPORT PUBLIC TRANSPORT   RAMM RAMM RAMM   REFUSE & RECYCLING REFUSE & RECYCLING REFUSE & RECYCLING   RETROFIT RETROFIT RETROFIT   ROYAL DEVON NHS TRUST ROYAL DEVON NHS TRUST ROYAL DEVON NHS TRUST   SIDWELL STREET SIDWELL STREET SIDWELL STREET   SOUTH WEST EXETER EXTENSION SOUTH WEST EXETER EXTENSION SOUTH WEST EXETER EXTENSION   SOUTH WEST WATER SOUTH WEST WATER SOUTH WEST WATER   SOUTHERNHAY SOUTHERNHAY SOUTHERNHAY   SPORT ENGLAND LOCAL DELIVERY PILOT SPORT ENGLAND LOCAL DELIVERY PILOT SPORT ENGLAND LOCAL DELIVERY PILOT   ST JAMES NEIGHBOURHOOD PLAN ST JAMES NEIGHBOURHOOD PLAN ST JAMES NEIGHBOURHOOD PLAN   ST SIDWELL'S COMMUNITY CENTRE ST SIDWELL'S COMMUNITY CENTRE ST SIDWELL'S COMMUNITY CENTRE   ST SIDWELL'S POINT ST SIDWELL'S POINT ST SIDWELL'S POINT   STAGECOACH SOUTH WEST STAGECOACH SOUTH WEST STAGECOACH SOUTH WEST   STUDENT ACCOMMODATION STUDENT ACCOMMODATION STUDENT ACCOMMODATION   TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL   TRANSPORT POLICY TRANSPORT POLICY TRANSPORT POLICY   UNIVERSITY OF EXETER UNIVERSITY OF EXETER UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   WATER LANE WATER LANE WATER LANE  

More stories