NEWS

University of Exeter ranked bottom of Russell Group and 103rd overall in social mobility league table

Landmark study by Institute for Fiscal Studies, Sutton Trust and Department for Education finds University of Exeter undergraduates are less likely to come from disadvantaged backgrounds, and those that do are less likely to be high earners.

Martin Redfern

A landmark study of the role of higher education in social mobility has placed the University of Exeter joint bottom in a league table of Russell Group universities, because of its relatively low levels of students from disadvantaged backgrounds and their relatively low earnings after graduation.

It was ranked 103rd overall in a survey of 111 higher education institutions in England.

The research was performed by the Institute for Fiscal Studies in partnership with The Sutton Trust and the Department for Education.

It analysed data on socio-economic background, education pathways and adult labour market outcomes for several entire school cohorts, covering close to the full population of England, to provide the clearest picture yet of how higher education attendance influences social mobility chances.

A social mobility rate was calculated for universities, subjects and individual degrees, based on entrance rates for students from disadvantaged backgrounds and how many of them go on to be high earners after graduation.

Eligibility for free school meals at sixteen was used as the marker of disadvantage, while adult earnings were measured at age 30 to allow time for careers to stabilise and mature.

Universities social mobility scatter chart showing University of Exeter ranking Universities social mobility scatter chart. Source: The Sutton Trust.

Equal access to university and an equal chance of labour market success for those who attend it would yield a social mobility rate of 4.4% using this research methodology.

Seven universities met or exceeded this benchmark, demonstrating that high levels of social mobility can be achieved via higher education even in the current context of wider inequality.

Queen Mary, University of London recorded the highest mobility rate of 6.8% at the top of a group of higher education institutions which combine high access rates for students from disadvantaged backgrounds with high levels of labour market success.

The University of Exeter recorded equal lowest social mobility rate in the Russell Group at 0.3%, combining relatively low levels of students from disadvantaged backgrounds with their relatively low earnings after graduation.

It also came ninth from bottom in the national rankings of all higher education institutions in England, just above a handful of specialist institutions including performing arts and drama colleges with low levels of students from disadvantaged backgrounds who also have low earnings prospects.

Russell Group universities social mobility rates (%)

Queen Mary, University of London6.8
King's College, London2.9
London School of Economics2.8
Imperial College, London2.3
University College, London2.0
University of Liverpool1.1
University of Manchester1.0
University of Birmingham1.0
University of Warwick0.7
University of Sheffield0.7
University of Nottingham0.6
University of Durham0.6
University of Leeds0.6
University of Southampton0.5
University of Cambridge0.5
University of York0.5
University of Oxford0.5
University of Bristol0.4
University of Exeter0.3
University of Newcastle Upon Tyne0.3

Social mobility scores are the percentage of students eligible for free school meals at sixteen who were in the top 20% of earners at age 30. Exeter is placed above Newcastle in the table because its graduates from disadvantaged backgrounds have slightly better earnings prospects.

The study recommended several changes, including increased use of widening participation and social mobility measures in university rankings. Universities are currently rewarded for the school grades of the students they take, a measure which discourages access improvements.

It also recommended that the most selective universities make more ambitious use of contextual admissions to widen access. This might include making reduced grade offers to students from disadvantaged backgrounds, reaching out to attract applicants from more diverse communities and providing direct financial support.

Goldsmiths College, in twelfth place overall with a social mobility rate of 3.6%, one of the highest among “old” universities, demonstrates this approach.

It actively recruits students who live near its South East London campus and offers a range of scholarships, bursaries and fee waivers for local residents on low incomes, students from Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, students in financial hardship, students who live in low participation in higher education postcodes, and students who have been in care, are estranged from their families or are refugees or asylum seekers.

Top ten university social mobility rates (%)

Queen Mary, University of London6.8
University of Westminster5.6
City University5.3
University of Greenwich5.0
London South Bank University4.6
Brunel University4.4
St George's Hospital Medical School4.4
University of East London4.1
London Metropolitan University4.0
Kingston University4.0

Among a total of 111 higher education institutions in England. 4.4% = full equality.

Many of the top-ranking institutions for social mobility are less selective universities, which take on the majority of students from disadvantaged backgrounds and are also located in large cities where employment opportunities are greater.

In particular, graduates from London and the South East are more likely to work in the capital after university, where salaries are higher, while London has a higher share of high achieving students from disadvantaged backgrounds than anywhere else in the country.

Three London universities (King’s College, Imperial College and London School of Economics) have such high success rates for the disadvantaged pupils they do admit that their relatively low access rates are partly counterbalanced in their social mobility scores.

Overall, more selective institutions offer the best chance of becoming a higher earner, but while access to these institutions has improved in the last two decades, those selective universities which have high social mobility rates demonstrate that much more can be done by other selective institutions which have low social mobility rates.

Bottom ten university social mobility rates (%)

University of Winchester0.4
University of Exeter0.3
University of Newcastle Upon Tyne0.3
Conservatoire for Dance and Drama0.3
Liverpool Institute for Performing Arts0.3
Central School of Speech and Drama0.3
York St John University College0.2
Rose Bruford College0.2
Arts Institute at Bournemouth0.2
Trinity LABAN Conservatoire of Music and Dance0.0

Among a total of 111 higher education institutions in England. 4.4% = full equality.

The research used data from a cohort of nearly a million young people who attended university in the mid-2000s and recently turned 30, supplemented with data for more recent cohorts including those who entered university between 2012 and 2014 and those who entered in 2018 and 2019.

Controls were included for a range of background characteristics, and broader income groups and different definitions of social mobility were also assessed for impact on the results.

Members of the mid-2000s cohort who were eligible for free school meals were 100 times less likely to attend Oxbridge than those who attended a private secondary school.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

Since then the most selective Russell Group universities (Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial and the London School of Economics) have increased the proportion of students they take from disadvantaged backgrounds from 1.7% to 2.2%, while the proportion entering the wider Russell Group has increased from 2.6% to 3.7%.

The research nevertheless found that success rates should not be adjusted for those institutions at which access rate changes had taken place, although Russell Group universities have tended to increase access the least while “old” universities and the least selective institutions have increased access the most.

Overall, university graduates remain nearly three times as likely as non-graduates to be among the top fifth of earners by age 30 while disadvantaged young people who don’t attend higher education are much more likely to end up in the lowest income groups.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
Northbrook swimming pool

City council holds sham Northbrook swimming pool closure consultation

£600,000 Exeter Leisure services budget cut signed off two weeks before pool consultation opened as St Sidwell’s Point drains other council leisure sites.

Met Office building at Exeter Science Park

Met Office to sell Exeter Science Park supercomputer and office buildings

Disposal motivated by replacement of nine year-old supercomputer with £1.2 billion government-funded off-site Microsoft facility.

St Petrock's outreach workers with a rough sleeper

Annual city council rough sleeper count “consistently underestimates” extent of Exeter rough sleeping

Homelessness charity St Petrock’s calls on council to change count methodology which identifies fewer rough sleepers than those known by outreach workers and reflected in government figures.

Devon County Council budget meeting 20 February 2025

Devon County Council reveals perilous financial state with SEND spending having “significant impact” on cash balances

5.9% budget increase for 2025-26 conceals £22 million cuts and £66 million cost increases with “inevitable” impact on “vital” services.

Grace Road Fields March 2025

Exeter Energy insists Riverside Valley Park only viable heat plant site but fails to explain Marsh Barton brownfield rejection

Company admits River Exe water source connection merely “potential” after 2036, incinerator connection only “possible” after 2030 and solar array “will not” meet plant electricity demand while statutory objections challenge Grace Road Fields plans.

Exeter Community Lottery revenue distribution FAQ

Exeter Community Lottery income spent on gambling licence fees and costs despite council marketing and point of sale claims

Materially misleading claims that 60% of ticket sales revenue goes to good causes repeatedly made on lottery website and in official council communications as Australian multinational profits from local voluntary and community sector support.

On Our Radar
Titus Andronicus by Nicholas Rowe

THURSDAY 3 APRIL 2025

Titus Andronicus

Lightbear Lane hosts a reading of Shakespeare’s bloody revenge tale.

ST NICHOLAS PRIORY

Jess Hughes Cameron and Chin See at 2024 Topsham Music Festival

FRIDAY 25 TO SUNDAY 27 APRIL 2025

2025 Topsham Music Festival

Three day event features jazz, percussion and classical music played by young professional musicians from across the country.

TOPSHAM

Liberation in Venice 1945

SUNDAY 27 APRIL 2025

Festa Di Liberazione

Italian Cultural Association Exeter hosts a day of music, dance, poetry and Italian culture.

KALEIDER