COMMENT

Exeter protest misses its mark by mixing its messages

One of Exeter’s biggest ever street demonstrations combined anti-Brexit and pro-democracy concerns to produce a confused protest against government policy.

Peter Cleasby

An estimated two thousand people packed Exeter’s Bedford Square on Saturday 31 August to protest against the government’s Brexit policies and its highly controversial decision to prorogue parliament for five weeks from 10 September.

Exeter MP Ben Bradshaw said it was one of the biggest gatherings he had seen in the 23 years he has represented the city, and paid tribute to Conservative MPs prepared to put national interest before party loyalty.

South West MEP Caroline Voaden argued that the European Parliament was far more effective at scrutinising legislation and keeping EU bureaucracy in check than anything that went on at Westminster.

Totnes MP Sarah Wollaston said the final Brexit deal should be put to the people in a referendum and if not, there should be a general election.

Also on the platform were speakers from campaigning organisation Devon for Europe and the trade union movement, a leave voter who had changed his mind about Brexit since the June 2016 referendum, and Phil Bialyk, Leader of Exeter City Council, whose delight at the size of the crowd moved him to plug the renationalisation of the railways.

Exeter anti-government protest Devon for Europe speaker

The demonstration combined two main, but muddled, lines of protest. On the one hand were those whose principal goal is to stop Brexit, or at least a no-deal Brexit. On the other were those protesting against the government’s decision to prorogue parliament for the longest period in more than 40 years.

These are very distinct issues: the first a matter of policy, the second an affront to democracy itself.

Most points made in the speeches about Brexit were already familiar, and it was only when speakers touched on constitutional issues that anything new came forward.

Mike Finn, a trade union speaker who teaches history at the University of Exeter, reminded the crowd that parliament can play a vital role at times of national emergency, such as when it replaced Chamberlain’s feeble government with the wartime coalition led by Churchill and Attlee.

Exeter anti-government protestor

So what was the protest’s purpose? Exeter city councillor Hannah Packham, one of its organisers, said she saw prorogation of parliament as its focus. Chris Bray of Devon for Europe emphasised opposition to Brexit, including demands for a second vote, though he also recognised the importance of prorogation. Ben Bradshaw simply said it was both.

Demonstrators’ clothing reflected this ambiguity. Those dressed in the vivid blue of the European flag were in stark contrast with the sober dress of the majority, which matched the greyness of the morning and made their allegiances less visible.

The Devon for Europe speaker, both on the platform and in the crowd, enthusiastically waved her flag and led chants of: “What do we want? Democracy! When do we want it? Now!”

Given that the problem is not that the UK doesn’t have democracy but has a version of it that allows charlatans and extremists to take charge, this may not have been the most appropriate chorus.

Not to mention the much-discussed democratic deficit in the EU’s governance structures.

Exeter anti-government protest

One reason for the mixed messages may have been that the protest had at least two organisers. Exeter Labour Party were responsible for the platform arrangements and Facebook promotion while Another Europe is Possible claims to have co-ordinated the 30 or so rallies that took place around the country on the same day.

While this organisation is unambiguously pro-remain, it has extended its scope to cover the current constitutional crisis using the hashtag #StopTheCoup.

Was the protest a vehicle for opponents of Brexit to use the controversy surrounding prorogation of parliament to bolster the anti-Brexit campaign? Or was it an expression of disgust at the government’s contempt for the constitution?

Either way, this and similar popular demonstrations do not appear have given ministers much pause for thought.


Democracy doesn't work when people don't know who is deciding what on whose behalf and what the costs and consequences of those decisions will be.

Exeter Observer is proving that reader-funded media can deliver the independent public interest journalism our local democracy needs.

Upgrade to a paid Exeter Observer subscription to support our work and get access to exclusive premium content and more.

More stories
His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary Fire and Rescue Services logo

HMICFRS identifies sufficient Devon & Cornwall Police improvements to return force to routine monitoring

Inspectorate decision follows nearly three years of enhanced monitoring after force found inadequate in three of nine areas and requiring improvement in two more, but says “still work to do” in crime recording standards and investigations management.

Devon & Cornwall Police deputy chief constable Jim Colwell, previous chief constable Will Kerr and interim chief constable James Vaughan

Devon & Cornwall Police deputy chief constable Jim Colwell receives 18-month misconduct warning

Outcome of Independent Office for Police Conduct investigation delivered day before retirement of suspended chief constable Will Kerr announced, with Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez unwilling to say whether “golden handshake” agreed.

Newtown active travel scheme map

Newtown active travel scheme approved after four years of public consultations

Joint Devon County Council and Exeter City Council project includes road closure, car parking changes and contraflow Clifton Hill cycle lane.

South West peninsula 2025 spending review road and rail investment map

Dawlish rail resilience, Exeter A379 bridge renewal and Cullompton M5 J28 schemes all shelved after spending review

Government road and rail funding announcement billed as “the biggest boost to England's transport infrastructure in a generation” largely passes Devon and Cornwall by while leaving final phase of South West Rail Resilience Programme undelivered.

Illustrative floor plan of new redevelopment proposals

New Heavitree Road police station student accommodation and “co-living” complex proposals submitted to Exeter City council

Application for full planning permission for 813-room scheme in seven blocks follows decision to reject previously-proposed 955-room scheme in two blocks which was subsequently upheld at appeal.

On Our Radar
Summer at the Quayside illustration

TUESDAY 29 JULY TO FRIDAY 29 AUGUST 2025

Summer at the Quayside

A month of free family activities including weaving, felting, doodling and drumming.

EXETER QUAY

Spork! summer special

THURSDAY 31 JULY TO THURSDAY 14 AUGUST 2025

Theatre in the Park

Exeter Phoenix hosts an al fresco summer theatre season featuring Shakespeare, spoken-word poetry, puppetry and physical comedy.

ROUGEMONT GARDENS

Exeter quayside farmers market vegetables

SATURDAY 16 AUGUST 2025

Quayside Farmers’ Market

Monthly market offering local produce, hand-made goods, plants, cakes and more.

EXETER QUAY