NEWS

Devon & Cornwall Police monitoring level increased again by police inspectorate

Police and crime commissioner Alison Hernandez says she has “full confidence” in chief constable James Vaughan two weeks after confirming he will lead force until August 2028 as HMICFRS highlights leadership and safeguarding failings.

Leigh Curtis

His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary Fire and Rescue Services has again increased its monitoring of Devon & Cornwall Police after it found that the force is “failing to provide effective leadership to manage demand, investigate crime and safeguard victims”.

The inspectorate has moved Devon & Cornwall Police from level two to level three, just below the highest level of concern in the new policing performance system it introduced earlier this year.

Its decision follows an inspection which took place in August after which it also reported an accelerated cause of concern – a designation used when it finds “significant service failures or risks to public safety” – because it found the force’s performance had deteriorated against causes of concern identified in an inspection it conducted last year.

The outcome of this inspection was published in June. The inspectorate found that Devon & Cornwall Police was underperforming in six of the eight areas it assessed, a decline in performance compared with its previous assessment. It also highlighted concerns over how the force investigated crime and safeguarded vulnerable children and adults.

Devon & Cornwall Police spent three years in “enhanced monitoring” under the previous policing performance framework after HMICFRS said that the force needed to make “urgent improvements” following a 2022 inspection.

The inspectorate eventually returned the force to routine monitoring in August last year.

Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez and Chief Constable James Vaughan Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez and Chief Constable James Vaughan. Photo: Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner.

HMICFRS introduced its new policing performance system in July, when it assigned each police force in England and Wales a performance level between one and four. Level four-designated forces are subject to special measures.

Devon & Cornwall Police was initially placed in level two, assigned to forces with “some low-level, non-systemic issues, issues which are getting better but require oversight, or multiple minor issues”.

This level attracts “enhanced support” from the inspectorate to “prevent any deterioration in performance”.

Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez welcomed the assessment at the time, although she said the force needed to reach level one because “that is the standard the public deserves and expects”.

She added that she was confident that Devon & Cornwall Police Chief Constable James Vaughan was “leading the force in a very positive direction”.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

The subsequent HMICFRS decision to move Devon & Cornwall Police to level three monitoring came just two weeks after Alison Hernandez announced that James Vaughan would stay in his post for another two years.

James Vaughan joined Devon & Cornwall Police on an interim basis in December 2024 following the suspension of acting chief constable Jim Colwell, who had been appointed following the suspension of chief constable Will Kerr in 2023.

Responding to the inspectorate’s decision, Alison Hernandez said that while she had “full confidence” in the chief constable the issues raised by HMICFRS had “come as no surprise”.

Last November the government announced it would abolish the role of Police and Crime Commissioner in May 2028, when incumbents’ terms of office end, three months before James Vaughan is now set to leave the force.

It said doing so would “cut the cost of unnecessary bureaucracy” and save “at least £100 million”.