SPECIAL REPORTS

Wonford hub plans scaled back as lease termination, business plan and governance risks remain unresolved

Labour councillors insist protracted project still on course after repeated delays expose funding dependence on time-limited £2 million Sport England grant.

Martin Redfern

Exeter City Council is to scale back the plans it approved in February 2025 for the redevelopment of Wonford Community & Learning Centre and the adjacent Wonford Sports Centre after having to finance most of the new Wonford hub construction costs itself.

The project is now on its ninth design iteration following a protracted development process which has been beset with delays and has cost the council in excess of £1 million.

Council officers called an extraordinary general meeting in haste six months ago to ask councillors to agree a capital budget for the project because Sport England had approved a time-limited £2 million contribution to redevelopment costs twelve months earlier – which had been conditional on the council finding match-funding for the remaining project costs by the end of March this year.

Doing so by-passed the checks and balances which council executive decision-making and accompanying scrutiny processes are supposed to provide.

The council cut the project budget by £1.5 million in the process, saying revisions to the planned building designs would follow to match the reduced budget.

The resulting £6 million budget depends on it collecting £3 million in projected Community Infrastructure Levy charges and £1 million in projected Section 106 charges from other developments to meet Sport England’s deadline after not being able to find any other way to pay for the project.

If it fails to realise these receipts it is expected to have to borrow any shortfall.

Wonford community learning centre and sports centre Wonford community learning centre and sports centre. Image: Exeter City Council.

The redevelopment involves demolition of two of the buildings on the site and the construction of a new building between the remaining sports and community halls to provide a single entrance to all the facilities. These will include a new café, changing facilities, a studio and a gym.

The revised project plans, which were published last month for approval by council planning officers, make several changes to the design approved in February last year.

These include reducing the new building’s footprint by 182m2, so it will be 16% smaller than planned, revising the layout, altering elevations and omitting design features such as circulation area roof lights and sun tunnels.

The footprint of the new café will be cut by a quarter from 165m2 to 123m2 and the planned climbing wall, parenting room, toddler play area and some of the changing rooms will not be provided. The community hall will also now not be refurbished as part of the project.

The resulting facility will be 200m2 smaller than the approved plans at just under 2,150m2 overall.

Wonford community hub revised design rear Wonford community hub revised design rear. Image: Space & Place.

At a council scrutiny committee meeting held last week it emerged that negotiations around the surrender of leases held over parts of the existing buildings, which the council identified as a critical issue eighteen months ago, have still not been completed.

They include a secure 30-year lease of the community hall on the east side of the site which runs for another ten years to Wonford Community & Learning Centre, a local charity which organises and administers most of the activities on the site which are not delivered directly by Exeter City Council leisure services as part of the adjacent Wonford Sports Centre.

The charity also sublets the Phoenix Suite building in the centre of the site from Devon County Council, which holds a secure 125-year lease which does not expire until 2113.

In addition, Exeter Community Energy Company holds a 20-year lease of the community hall roof, which also runs for another ten years, on which it installed solar panels in 2015 to provide the building with electricity and from which it derives significant income.

A report to the council’s extraordinary meeting in March by council development director Ian Collinson said the tenants would have to surrender these leases for the council to secure vacant possession before building works began.

It added: “The time frame for obtaining vacant possession is critical to the project; the terms for the lease surrenders need to be agreed before the tender process commences in August, with agreements being documented before the construction contract is let in October/November.

“Construction contracts must not be signed until there is a clear route to obtaining vacant possession; to do otherwise would represent a significant risk to the council.”

It also said that there was “no certainty on securing vacant possession of the leased areas” and that the cost to the council of terminating the leases was “unknown”.

Wonford community hub revised design front Wonford community hub revised design front. Image: Space & Place.

Ian Collinson’s report should have made clear, but did not, whether the project budget included an allowance for lease termination costs. Councillors were instead only provided with a single-page project costs summary. A detailed cost estimates report disclosed by Sport England under freedom of information legislation includes no such allowance, however.

It is also unclear why his report said that Wonford Community & Learning Centre and Exeter Community Energy Company would have to surrender their community hall leases when the redevelopment plans only require the demolition of the buildings in the centre of the site.

An earlier council summary of governance and management options nevertheless suggests that the council intends to assume operational control over the whole hub, relegating Wonford Community & Learning Centre trustees and “other stakeholders” to membership of a “steering group”.

This appears to be intended primarily to confer eligibility for supplementary grant funding income, which the council estimated at just £5,000 a year. And it appears any risk that the trustees might oppose plans for the council to take control of the community centre (and the income it generates) has already been dealt with by the appointment of several Labour party members to its board.

Wonford community hub revised design plan Wonford community hub revised design plan. Image: Space & Place.

Ian Collinson’s report also included a project schedule, adherence to which it also described as “critical” if the council were to meet Sport England’s £2 million grant funding conditions. This said that the revised building designs for the hub on which the reduced £6 million budget depended would be published in March and approved in April.

Despite their publication in August, five months later then scheduled, Labour councillor and leisure services portfolio holder Duncan Wood insisted that there had been no delays, and that the project remained on schedule, at last week’s scrutiny meeting.

Council leader Phil Bialyk then claimed that the lease terminations would all be agreed before November, simply adding that council officers were “dealing with it” when pressed by Green Party councillor Lynn Wetenhall to confirm that the lease agreements would all be completed before construction contracts were signed.

This is what the council said eighteen months ago too, according to other documents disclosed by Sport England under freedom of information legislation, when it told Sport England that its corporate property team was already working on the lease terminations because it expected them to require “significant corporate property and legal input”.

As for the “revised detailed business case” and accompanying project risk register which Ian Collinson’s report said would be submitted as part of the revised design planning application, neither have materialised.

Nor has the council resolved the hub’s future governance arrangements. Sport England expects Wonford Community & Learning Centre to be directly involved in management decisions, but nothing has so far been agreed. Ian Collinson’s report also rolled the pitch for a council leisure services takeover when it said there was “no current certainty” on the hub’s future operating model.

At last week’s scrutiny meeting Lynn Wetenhall asked what alternative governance arrangements might be adopted if the charity did not continue working with the council on the project.

Labour councillor and communities portfolio holder Liz Pole replied that the council hadn’t considered any other governance options. She then said the risk of the charity pulling out was “hypothetical”.

Wonford community hub option one plan Wonford community hub option one plan. Image: Space & Place.

The idea of improving the Wonford facilities was first raised in a May 2015 council consultant’s report. The following year, ownership of the community centre building was transferred from the county to the city council as part of the closure of several Exeter youth centres.

In June 2018 the city council said plans to “reposition Wonford Sports Centre as a community hub where sport and physical activity can be used to develop community health and wellbeing opportunities” were being developed by Parkwood Leisure, then the centre operator, to “contribute to the priorities set out in the Sport England Local Delivery Pilot programme”.

This programme had begun earlier that year with the aim of addressing health inequalities that obstruct access to sport and physical activity. Initially funded with £100 million of National Lottery money over four years, it was focussed in twelve pilot areas across the country, including a £4.7 million Exeter and Cranbrook pilot delivered under the Live & Move banner.

In February 2019 Phil Bialyk, who was then health, wellbeing, communities and sport portfolio holder, hailed a new council plan to create “an innovative, new-build integrated community health and wellbeing centre to replace the existing Wonford sports and community centres” as part of its Built Facilities, Playing Fields, Pitches, Play Areas, Parks And Green Spaces strategy.

This said a “flagship” development would be “designed with the local community, building on the aspirational proposals put forward in 2016”, while a subsequent council officer’s report said a Wonford “blueprint and site master plan” would be ready by December 2019. It also said a business case which would “need to set out financial strategies for the capital and revenue consequences of the proposals” would be prepared, although no deadline was given for its delivery.

The council’s December 2019 follow-up report failed to mention the master plan. But it did say a design brief would be completed by July 2020 and a full business case would be brought back for approval by councillors “by December 2020”.

Numerous surveys and design options followed, but by January 2021 council officers were telling stakeholders that business modelling would still not be complete for “about a year”.

Wonford community hub option two plan Wonford community hub option two plan. Image: Space & Place.

Thirteen months later, in February 2022, council officers presented a strikingly slight “feasibility proposal” to the council executive committee asking for £750,000 “to progress to the next workstage” of the Wonford hub project.

It described the three years the council had spent on the project since February 2019 as its “initial co-design phase” then skated through the six work-streams the new funding was to pay for in less than 400 words.

It said that everything, including “further detailed feasibility” work and the submission of a full planning application for the redevelopment, was “expected to take 12 to 14 months to complete”.

What it didn’t say was that everything done thus far had been based on the council’s assumption that the existing buildings would be demolished completely in favour of a “flagship new-build”.

The council was nevertheless privately admitting that it had gone back to the drawing board to cut costs because the “new build would run the risk of not being financially possible” and was instead pursuing what it called an “extension and improvement” approach.

It also admitted that this option had not been developed during what it called “the feasibility stage” so would require “further surveys and exploratory work” meaning it would now take “circa three and a half years” to complete the project.

Then, in October 2022, the council publicly acknowledged that it would also need external investment to deliver the project – even if it only amounted to refurbishment and partial extension.

Wonford community hub option three plan Wonford community hub option three plan. Image: Space & Place.

In March 2023 it emerged that an “initial draft business plan” for the hub was finally being prepared. The council subsequently said: “A formal business case is being developed to identify the capital and revenue costing models for the building” with it getting “closer to planning in late 2023”.

The council eventually published a business case in April 2024. An accompanying report claimed that this demonstrated “how Wonford could be taken from loss-making to profit in the first five years”.

The included figures showing an existing annual deficit of around £220,000 – of which £200,000 was accounted for not by the community centre but by the council’s leisure service losses.

Remarkably, they also forecast the hub’s net income increasing by £267,000 within two years of reopening before turning a profit in year three.

The council expected income from leisure service memberships to more than double over the course of five years – from £360,000 in year one to £734,000 in year five – and to bring in £100,000 a year from the new cafe from the day it opened.

It forecast total hub income of nearly £600,000 in year one, rising to more than £1 million in year five, even though its own research showed that, because of “affordability”, 70% of the local residents it had consulted had never used the leisure centre and 64% had never used the community centre.

At the same time the council admitted that not achieving these financial results could mean “cuts to services, requirement for subsidy or even closure of the facility”. No allowance for the potential cost of capital borrowing to fund the building works was included.

An accompanying “indicative programme timeline”, based on funding for the estimated £7 million project costs being immediately available, imagined a planning application submission in May 2024, work starting on site in April 2025 and completion in April this year.

Wonford community hub option four plan Wonford community hub option four plan. Image: Space & Place.

The council did not submit its redevelopment plans until November 2024. It approved them three months later then immediately applied to Sport England for a £2 million capital grant towards the redevelopment costs, by then estimated at £7.35 million.

As part of its application, the council told Sport England it would seek to fill the project funding gap with money from “other local system stakeholders”, “philanthropists” and “community funding models” as well as other national funding bodies.

It also said it was “committed to exploring funding to match Sport England funding from its own resources”.

An internal Sport England report produced in response to the council’s funding application, disclosed under freedom of information legislation, recommended that the £2 million award be granted despite the “significant risks attached to the delivery of the project” it identified.

These included what it described as “the applicant’s track record of developing the scheme”, the termination of the leases and subleases on the site, the unresolved future governance and management arrangements and, crucially, the “lack of confirmed match funding” for the project.

It said this had been “evident at the time of the Expression of Interest being approved in late October 2024” and added that “the position has not improved significantly since then”.

It also noted that the council’s business case for the hub had not been revised since March 2024, a year earlier, and said it would need updating “to take account of the proposed management approach and any changes to the design”.

The report concluded that Sport England could protect its investment in the hub by imposing conditions on the council, including a twelve-month time-limit on the council raising the missing match-funding, without which “consideration should be given to withdrawing any award offer”.

It also said “satisfactory updating of the business case” should be a condition of the award, with “key milestones around funding and leases needing to be met in the next six months to avoid further delays and potential cost increases”.

An accompanying draft funding agreement, also disclosed under freedom of information legislation, said the council would have to confirm all the required match-funding by 31 March 2026 and ensure that the project would be completed and the new hub opened by 31 July 2027.

It added that, should the council fail to satisfy the conditions of the award agreement within 18 months of the date on which it was signed, it might have to give Sport England its money back.

Sport England approved the £2 million grant on 20 March 2025. But the council said nothing, and a report “seeking approval to proceed to the next phase of the scheme” which had been set to appear on the 1 April 2025 executive committee agenda since the previous October vanished without trace.

Wonford community hub option six plans Wonford community hub option six plan. Image: Space & Place.

Another year passed. Duncan Wood appeared before a council scrutiny committee meeting in March but couldn’t answer the questions he was asked about the hub’s governance issues by Green Party councillor Diana Moore because, he said, he hadn’t been involved in them.

Lynn Wetenhall said she was shocked that so little detail about Wonford hub had been included in Duncan Wood’s report to the committee when so much money was involved. She asked about the project schedule, its funding status and whether it was wise to pursue in the context of local government reorganisation. Duncan Wood said more details would be available in due course.

The following week, council officers called the extraordinary meeting at which councillors were bounced into committing £4 million of uncollected development charges to a reduced £6 million Wonford hub project budget because Sport England’s match-funding deadline was approaching.

Three days later it was the turn of Labour councillor and then-city management portfolio holder Ruth Williams to produce a report for scrutiny.

She said the council’s capital programme, which includes the Wonford hub redevelopment, remained “inherently subject to procurement risk”, adding that “the successful delivery of projects is dependent on the timely and compliant award of contracts.”

She continued: “Where a procurement exercise does not attract suitable bids, fails to meet required standards, or cannot be awarded, this can result in unavoidable delays to project mobilisation and delivery programmes.

“Until tender processes are concluded and contracts are formally awarded, timelines should therefore be considered indicative rather than confirmed.”

Wonford community hub option seven plan Wonford community hub option seven plan. Image: Space & Place.

Perhaps because so many other issues with the project remained unresolved, or perhaps because so many delays had occurred along the way that more seemed inevitable, Ian Collinson’s report to the March extraordinary meeting did not address these procurement risks or their potential to push project delivery beyond the limits of Sport England’s funding conditions.

Instead, it rehearsed the issues raised by the extant leases, unfinished business plan and unresolved governance and management arrangements and summarised the value engineering exercise which had led to the council selecting the cheapest alternative design it could come up with in order to get the redevelopment costs down.

It claimed a “detailed review” of the future hub’s operating income and costs had taken place, but only provided a single line summary of its revised five year forecasts which showed that the council now apparently thought that year one losses would be only half what it had previously said.

The report was accompanied by the draft Sport England funding agreement, with the dates changed to give the council three additional months – until 30 June 2026 – to find the match-funding. So it seems council officers need not have called an extraordinary meeting, bypassing democratic checks and balances, to get councillors to approve the budget after all.

Having sprung the decision on councillors, Ian Collinson found himself answering numerous questions, although he added little to what had already been said. He did, however, when asked about financial lease termination and procurement risks, say that there was always scope to come back to councillors to ask for more money.

Subscribe to The Exeter Digest - Exeter Observer's essential free email newsletter

Your personal information will be processed and stored in accordance with our Privacy Policy

During the debate that followed, several councillors raised concerns about the risks entailed by leaving so many critical matters unresolved while committing so much money to such a tight delivery timetable which left the council on the hook for another £2 million if it couldn’t deliver by the deadlines set by Sport England.

Council leader Phil Bialyk spoke last, becoming more prolix as he approached his peroration. He said, reacting to Lynn Wetenhall’s contribution to the debate: “You talked about pausing this, well, I hope you put that in your election leaflets going around the Priory ward, that we intend to pause this project in the interests of you because we’ve had a few people on to us.”

He concluded his speech by extolling council spending on St Sidwell’s Point and the Riverside leisure centre, then doubled down on turning the £6 million budget decision the council was about to make into a political party issue in the run-up to the May local elections, campaigning for which had already begun.

He said: “So it’s quite clear, people of Exeter, if you’re still awake, if you’re still awake, you’ve got a choice, you’ve got a choice. You can vote for these [opposition parties], who will bring you nothing, and just absolutely continue, or you can join us and bring Exeter a brighter future.”

In the event, residents in the Priory electoral ward, where the Wonford hub site sits, made other choices. Six weeks later Marina Asvachin, who has been a trustee of Wonford Community & Learning Centre since May 2023, lost her council seat there to Reform UK.


Comments on the revised Wonford community hub design can be submitted via the city council website until Sunday 27 September.